Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
Yes, medieval mail could be pierced by arrows under some conditions. Reproduction mail tested without padding did not adequately protect against arrows from bows described as moderate in strength. Linen or linen-and-cotton padding reduced both the chance and depth of penetration, but it did not make a wearer invulnerable. The result depends on the mail’s construction, the arrowhead, the bow, the impact conditions and what lies beneath the rings.
The short answer: mail was protection, not an arrow-proof shell
Chain mail, more precisely mail made from interlinked metal rings, was designed to prevent cutting attacks and distribute impact across a larger area. That is different from guaranteeing that a pointed projectile cannot pass through it. An arrow can concentrate force on a small point, and the outcome changes when the rings, arrowhead, bow and backing material change.
David Jones’s experimental chapter, Experimental Tests of Arrows against Mail and Padding, reports that reproduction mail worn without padding did not adequately protect against arrows fired from bows described as moderate in strength. When padding was worn beneath the mail, penetration became less likely and shallower in the reported tests. The study’s conclusion was risk reduction, not complete protection: a padded mail garment could still allow a potentially fatal injury.
That is why both absolute statements are misleading. Mail was not automatically defeated by every arrow, and it was not reliably immune to arrows. A controlled test compares one particular garment, projectile and shooting setup; a medieval battlefield included many more combinations.
Popular on Amazon
- Medieval Warrior Haubergeon Butted Chain Mail Replica Armor Long Shirts
What Jones tested and what the result actually means
The reproduction mail
The mail in Jones’s chapter was made from mild steel and used alternating rows of solid and riveted rings. That construction is important. Historical mail was not a single standardized product, so the behavior of this reproduction should not be treated as a measurement for every shirt, hood or chausses made in the Middle Ages. Ring dimensions, wire, rivets, heat treatment, corrosion and workmanship could all vary, but the accessible study summary does not provide a universal performance table for those variables.
Mail without a backing layer
In the reported tests, the unpadded mail did not provide adequate protection against the arrows used. This does not mean that every shot went straight through the rings. It means the setup allowed enough penetration or injury risk that the investigators could not regard mail alone as sufficient protection against that test condition.
Linen and linen with cotton wadding
Adding textile beneath the rings changed the result. Linen, and linen combined with cotton wadding, reduced the probability and depth of penetration in the reported experiments. Padding can absorb and spread part of the impact before it reaches the body, while also supporting the rings so that the garment does not simply move into the wearer. The tests still did not establish a safe thickness for every mail garment or arrow. Their practical message is comparative: the same mail performed better with a suitable backing than without one.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute2Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors3Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesWhat the summary does not establish
The publisher’s accessible summary gives no shot-by-shot penetration percentage, sample size, universal energy threshold or maximum range. It therefore cannot support a claim such as “mail stops arrows below a particular speed” or “a longbow always defeats mail.” Any video or article that supplies a single pass/fail number should identify its own bow, arrow, range, target angle, mail and backing rather than presenting that number as a medieval constant.
Why padding changes the outcome
Mail is flexible compared with a rigid plate. Without a substantial textile layer, an impact can push the rings toward the body even when the rings remain linked. A padded garment provides distance and resistance beneath the metal. It may also reduce blunt trauma by spreading the load over more area. Those effects explain why the tests compared mail alone with mail over linen and over linen with cotton wadding rather than treating “mail” as one condition.
Also popular on Amazon
- HANDMADE AND DURABLE CONSTRUCTION - Constructed from 10mm, 16-gauge mild steel rings with a zinc polish, ensuring a rust-resistant and maintenance-free product that lasts for years.
- VERSATILE FIT - Sized to fit chest sizes from 44” to 50” (large size), and designed to be worn over a gambeson for accurate fitting and comfort during activities.
- CLASSIC 4-in-1 PATTERN - Features a traditional 4-in-1 chainmail pattern, providing an authentic medieval appearance perfect for historical reenactments and cosplay.
- PERFECT FOR - LARP (Live Action Role-Playing), cosplay, Halloween costumes, fancy dress events, theatrical props, SCA (Society for Creative Anachronism) activities, and historical reenactments.
- CUSTOMER SATISFACTION FIRST – We are committed to providing high-quality products that meet your expectations. All warranty issues are handled directly by Mythrojan. If you receive a product that doesn't meet your expectations, contact us for a resolution.
Padding is not a magic barrier. The Jones summary says that it reduced penetration likelihood and depth but did not eliminate fatal injury. The material, weave, number of layers, compression and fit matter, and the evidence available for this article does not justify a universal rule that a specific number of linen layers would stop a specific arrow.
A numerical example from horse armour, kept in its proper context
Jones and Emma Herbert-Davies reported an experiment on mail horse armour in the EXARC Journal on 25 February 2022. In one test series, a 65 lb (289 N) bow and 15 mm of compressed woven linen beneath the mail were associated with preventing penetration greater than 10 mm.
Recommended Free Tools
Those figures are useful because they show how a backing layer and a defined test condition can be described numerically. They are not a human-armor standard. The target was horse armour, the result came from one series, and the quoted threshold concerns penetration greater than 10 mm in that setup. It should not be converted into a claim that a 65 lb bow could never injure a person in padded mail, or that 15 mm of linen was a universal medieval requirement.
| Evidence | Reported setup | Reported finding | What it cannot prove |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jones, Experimental Tests of Arrows against Mail and Padding | Mild-steel mail with alternating solid and riveted rings; bows described as moderate in strength; comparisons with no padding, linen and linen with cotton wadding | Unpadded mail did not adequately protect in the reported tests; textile backing reduced penetration probability and depth | A universal penetration rate, safe bow strength or result for every historical mail shirt |
| Jones and Herbert-Davies, EXARC Journal, 2022 | Horse mail; 65 lb (289 N) bow; 15 mm compressed woven linen in one series | Associated with preventing penetration greater than 10 mm in that series | A human-body threshold or a result for every horse or rider |
| Amgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales collection record | Long, thin iron bodkin arrowhead from Harlech Castle | Identified as intended for piercing mail and armour | A controlled demonstration that the artifact defeated every mail garment |
Could a bodkin pierce chain mail?
A bodkin is a narrow, pointed arrowhead form associated with piercing armour. The Museum Wales record for a medieval or post-medieval iron arrowhead found at Harlech Castle describes that particular object as a bodkin intended for piercing mail and armour. The record is valuable evidence of how the artifact was interpreted and what role such a point was meant to serve.
It is not a penetration experiment. The record does not tell us that the Harlech arrowhead was fired, what bow was used, the range or angle, which mail it struck, or whether it passed through. “Designed for piercing” describes intended function, not a guaranteed result against every shirt. A bodkin’s narrow profile may concentrate force differently from a broad cutting head, but the outcome still depends on the mail, backing and impact conditions.
Also popular on Amazon
- High Quality Fabric: The imitation chainmail shirt tunic is made of polyester. It is most comfortable to wear a shirt before wearing a chainmail tunic. The wrist guard and belt are made of PU leather.
- Medieval Imitation Chainmail Suit: This medieval-style imitation chainmail suit perfectly restores the classic costumes of the Renaissance.
- Renaissance Chain Mail Includes: a top, a belt, 2*arm armor, a sword sheath, presenting a complete image of a medieval knight.
- Retro Design: The well-designed costumes and accessories perfectly present the unique charm of the Middle Ages. Wearing a knight's belt and wrist guard, it seems to travel through time, become a member of the Renaissance, and experience that glorious historical moment.
- Wide Range of Applicable Occasions: This men's Renaissance costume is not only suitable for various activities such as medieval theme parties, stage performances, Halloween, historical reenactments, etc., but also adds a unique charm to masquerade balls and costume parties. Customize your knight look to make your costume stand out and become the focus of the audience.
The variables that prevent a single yes-or-no answer
Mail material and construction
Solid and riveted rings, wire thickness, ring diameter, steel quality and workmanship can alter how a garment responds. Jones’s reproduction used mild steel and alternating solid and riveted rows; historical examples outside that specification should not be assigned its exact performance.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Padding
No backing, several linen layers, and linen combined with cotton wadding are different protective systems. The reported tests found a substantial difference between those conditions, so “mail” without saying what was underneath is incomplete.
Arrowhead form
A narrow bodkin and a broader cutting or hunting point present different contact shapes. The available evidence identifies the Harlech point’s intended armour-piercing role but does not provide a controlled comparison with other heads.
Bow strength and arrow construction
The Jones summary describes the bows qualitatively as moderate in strength, without a universal draw-weight threshold. The horse-armour article gives 65 lb (289 N) for one series, but that number belongs to that experiment. Arrow mass, shaft stiffness, fletching and point attachment also affect impact, yet the accessible summaries do not supply a complete standardized set of those values.
Range, angle and movement
A stationary target struck squarely at a known distance is not the same as a moving person seen obliquely at battlefield range. Angle can make a point glance, while a near-perpendicular hit presents a more demanding test. Historical combat also involved shifting posture, shields, layered clothing and repeated impacts. Experimental archaeology can isolate variables; it cannot recreate every battlefield circumstance.
Also popular on Amazon
- DURABLE CONSTRUCTION - Made from sturdy 16-gauge mild steel with 10mm butted rings, this armor provides excellent durability and protection for all your medieval adventures.
- PERFECT FIT - Available in L, designed to fit chest sizes from 44” to 50”. Be sure to wear your costume or gambeson when taking measurements for the best fit.
- CLASSIC 4-in-1 PATTERN - Features a traditional 4-in-1 chainmail pattern, providing an authentic medieval appearance perfect for historical reenactments and cosplay.
- PERFECT FOR - LARP (Live Action Role-Playing), cosplay, Halloween costumes, fancy dress events, theatrical props, SCA (Society for Creative Anachronism) activities, and historical reenactments.
- CUSTOMER SATISFACTION FIRST – We are committed to providing high-quality products that meet your expectations. All warranty issues are handled directly by Mythrojan. If you receive a product that doesn't meet your expectations, contact us for a resolution.
How effective was mail against a longbow?
The available evidence does not justify a single longbow verdict. Jones’s study did not publish an accessible universal draw-weight or penetration threshold in the summary, and the 65 lb figure comes from a horse-armour series rather than a test of a person in a longbow-era shirt. It is therefore more accurate to say that some arrows from bows of meaningful strength could penetrate some unpadded mail, while padding improved the odds of avoiding deep penetration.
“Longbow” also describes a family of bows rather than one identical machine. Draw weight, arrow selection, distance and impact angle all matter. A video that demonstrates one bow and one reproduction can show what happened in that setup, but it cannot settle every question about medieval mail.
Human mail and horse mail are not interchangeable evidence
Horse armour tests are relevant because they demonstrate how mail and textile backing can be evaluated, and they provide the clearly stated 65 lb and 15 mm figures. They are not direct substitutes for human-armor tests. A horse target, its armour pattern and the way the material is supported differ from a person wearing a shirt or hood. Keep the target and test series attached whenever quoting the numerical result.
Likewise, evidence about projectile wounds in bone should not be used as a mail test. Eva Forsom and Martin J. Smith’s February 2017 experimental study examined how to identify penetrating projectile trauma to bone caused by medieval arrows. Its findings concern wound morphology and archaeological diagnosis, not whether an arrow passed through rings.
What experimental archaeology can—and cannot—tell us
Russ Mitchell’s chapter, “Archery versus Mail: Experimental Archaeology and the Value of Historical Context,” argues that ballistic testing should be interpreted alongside historical circumstances. That approach is useful here. Reproductions allow researchers to hold a bow, arrow, mail and backing constant, then observe differences when one element changes. They cannot recover the exact range of equipment used in every medieval encounter or reproduce fear, movement, weather, armor wear and multiple hits.
The strongest conclusion is therefore conditional rather than dramatic: mail was part of a protective system. Its performance improved when supported by padding, but even a padded setup retained residual risk. The right question is not whether chain mail “stopped arrows” in the abstract, but which mail, with which backing, against which arrow, from which bow, at what angle and distance.
How to assess a chain-mail arrow video
- Identify the mail. Check the metal, ring construction, riveted or solid rows, ring size and whether the garment is a historical original or a reproduction.
- Record the backing. Note whether the target is bare mail, linen, linen with cotton wadding or another material, and measure thickness if the producer provides it.
- Check the projectile. Look for the arrowhead form, shaft, mass and point attachment. A bodkin demonstration is not automatically a test of broad-headed arrows.
- Check the bow and range. A stated draw weight, measured draw length, arrow speed and shooting distance make the result more reproducible. “A powerful bow” is not a specification.
- Separate penetration from injury. A ring breach, a point entering a few millimetres, a deep wound and a fatal injury are different outcomes. The Jones summary specifically warns that reduced penetration did not remove fatal risk.
- Keep the target type attached. Do not transfer a horse-armour result directly to a person, or a bone-trauma study directly to mail performance.
Further reading
David Jones’s chapter appears in Journal of Medieval Military History, Volume XVIII, published online on 6 October 2020 and in print in 2020. The horse-armour evaluation by Jones and Emma Herbert-Davies was published by EXARC Journal on 25 February 2022. The Harlech arrowhead is documented by Amgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales. Mitchell’s context chapter is listed by its publisher online on 12 September 2012 and gives a print year of 2006.






Say something about this film