What WIRED’s 2019 article was really asking

Emma Grey Ellis’s WIRED Takes a Good Hard Look at Dick Pics, published on August 14, 2019, was not a study of its own. It was a reported synthesis of a young, uneven research field and of the cultural arguments surrounding unsolicited penis images.

Its most important move was to reject a false choice. A penis image is not automatically abusive merely because it depicts male nudity; mutually desired sexting can be intimate, playful, or erotic. But an unsolicited genital image is not transformed into a welcome sexual exchange simply because the sender hoped it would produce arousal. The decisive difference is consent.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
#1 Best Overall
Xenvo Pro Lens Kit for iPhone and Android, Macro and Wide Angle Lens with LED Light and Travel Case Black
  • ✔ COMPATIBLE WITH ALL SMARTPHONES, TABLETS, and LAPTOPS including ALL iPhone models, Samsung Galaxy and Note, Google Pixel, Huawei and more. CONTENTS INCLUDE: TruView 0.45x Wide Angle Lens, Clarus 15x Macro Lens, TruGrip Lens Clip, GlowClip Mini Rechargeable LED Light + Charging Cable, Quick-Release Lanyard, DuraCase, EasyClip, and Cleaning Cloth.
  • ✔ TRUVIEW 0.45x WIDE ANGLE LENS - CAPTURE 45% MORE PICTURE WITH EVERY SNAP: Shoot stunning photos of people, pets, travel scenery, landscapes, architecture, selfies and more. NO DARK CORNERS (vignetting) like cheaper lenses. Crafted from aircraft-grade aluminum and premium optical glass for durability and clarity. Multi-element, coated glass lenses minimize ghosting, reflections, lens flare, and other artifacts. Xenvo cell phone lens attachment is ideal for hobbyists and photography pros alike.
  • ✔ CLARUS 15x MACRO LENS - MARVEL YOUR SENSES. MAGNIFY NEARBY SUBJECTS FOR BREATHTAKING, SUPER CLOSE-UP PHOTOS: Capture all the intricacies and details with precision-focus for razor crisp macro photos every time. (For best results, position macro lens approximately 1/2 inch from subject. Not designed for zooming in on distant subjects.) THE TRUGRIP LENS CLIP offers SUPERIOR GRIPPING POWER to fasten your lenses to your cell phone when you're in action mode, framing your next perfect shot.
  • ✔ GLOWCLIP RECHARGEABLE LED FILL LIGHT - The GlowClip LED light clips ANYWHERE on your phone to instantly illuminate your subject and surroundings with warm continuous light. The warm and natural LED light is superior to your smartphone's built in flash—which can be blinding and unnatural—especially in darker settings and venues. FEATURES 3 BRIGHTNESS SETTINGS: Low, Medium and High. Say goodbye to frustrating photo "retakes" and hello to brilliant photos the first time.
  • ✔ QUICK-RELEASE LANYARD AND TRAVEL CASE - TRANSPORT AND PROTECT YOUR LENS KIT: Perfect for taking your Xenvo lenses with you on the fly. The travel case stores and protects all lens kit components snugly and safely while the quick-release lanyard is the perfect way to carry your lenses on your next outing. Just drape the lanyard and lens around your neck. The quick-release lanyard head makes it a cinch to access your Xenvo lenses in a flash so you never miss another photo moment.

Research has expanded since the article appeared. It has also confirmed why the subject needs careful language: senders are not one psychological type, recipients do not all react identically, and studies conducted in different countries with different populations cannot be combined into one universal statistic.

The short version of what the evidence shows

Question Best-supported answer
Does every genital image mean the same thing? No. A consensual exchange and an unsolicited image belong to different ethical and social categories.
Are unsolicited senders all motivated by hostility? No. Studies have found motives including hoped-for sexual excitement, reciprocity, validation, narcissism, sexism, and sometimes explicitly misogynistic ideas.
Do recipients generally respond as senders expect? Often not. The available evidence shows substantial discomfort and a recurring mismatch between intended or presumed reactions and recipients’ reported experiences.
Do all recipients find unsolicited images disgusting? No. Responses vary with the person, relationship, sexual orientation, context, power dynamics, and cultural setting.
Is cyberflashing illegal everywhere? No. England and Wales have a specific offense, but that rule should not be generalized to the rest of the United Kingdom, the United States, or the world.

Why some men send unsolicited images

The sender-side research discussed by WIRED came in part from Cory Pedersen’s work at Kwantlen Polytechnic University. WIRED reported that approximately half of the men in the studied group had sent an unsolicited genital image without qualms. The reported differences between unsolicited senders and other men centered on narcissism and sexism.

That finding is an association, not a diagnosis. It does not mean that every person who sends an unwanted image is a narcissist, a misogynist, or a sex offender. Nor does it identify a single personality profile that can explain the behavior.

The study’s title, I’ll Show You Mine so You’ll Show Me Yours, captures the most frequently reported motivational category: an expectation of reciprocity. Many senders appeared to view the image as an opening bid in a sexual exchange. The reaction they most commonly hoped to produce was sexual excitement. A small minority explicitly endorsed misogynistic reasons for sending.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Those details help explain the behavior without excusing it. A sender may genuinely believe that an image will lead to mutual exposure, flirtation, or validation. That belief can still be a projection onto someone who has not agreed to participate. Wanting a sexual reaction is not permission to demand one.

The study also illustrates a recurring problem in popular coverage: the word motive can quietly become a defense. Understanding that some senders expect reciprocity does not make an unsolicited image reciprocal. It explains the sender’s model of the interaction; it does not establish the recipient’s consent.

The recipient-side correction

One limitation in the 2019 discussion was the relative lack of robust evidence about how recipients actually felt. A later Journal of Sex Research study examined reactions among 2,045 women in the United States and 298 gay or bisexual men. Among participants who had ever received a genital image, 91 percent reported having received one unsolicited.

That number describes the study population, not all women or all gay and bisexual men. The sample, recruitment method, age distribution, and questions matter, and the result should not be turned into a worldwide prevalence estimate. It does, however, establish that unsolicited receipt was common among people in the study who had encountered genital images.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

The study is especially useful because it addresses the gap between what male senders expect and what recipients report. The hoped-for outcome of sexual excitement does not reliably materialize. Recipients’ reactions include discomfort, annoyance, fear, amusement, curiosity, arousal, indifference, and combinations of these feelings. The important pattern is not that everyone reacts in one way; it is that senders and recipients frequently do not share the same interpretation of the exchange.

Rank #2
Sale
Cell Phone Camera Lens Kit,11 in 1 Universal 20x Telephoto 0.63Wide Angle 15X Macro 198°Fisheye 2X Telephoto Kaleidoscope CPL Starlight Eyemask Tripod,for Most iPhone Smartphone (Black)
  • ★11-in-1 most complete mobile camera lens kit★:Bostionye phone camera lens kit is perfect for exploring more advanced mobile photography and Videography.Includes 8 lenses:20 times telephoto lens,0.63X wide angle Lens, 15X Macro lens, 198°Fisheye lens, 2X telephoto lens,Kaleidoscopes, 4-line star filter, CPL Filter.Auxiliary equipment:universal clip, tripod, eyecup and Bostionye storage bag。 (Note: macro lens and wide angle lens are screwed together).
  • ★With unique features★: 20x telephoto lens (fixed focus)-magnifies distant subjects and clearly presents long-distance vision. 198 ° fisheye lens-create interesting and unique circular mysterious effect pictures. 15x macro lens-Alignment lens for shooting flowers, insects and other small objects (optimal shooting distance: 1 to 3 inches).0.63X ultra wide-angle lens-capture a large field of view to get an amazing angle of view (The wide-angle lens should be used with a macro lens).
  • ★Create surprise★:The unique functions of each small lenses can be seen in detail in the auxiliary picture display.tripod for easy shooting,An eyecup also allows you to use the telephoto lens as a monocular or a telescope.It is a good companion in the tourism industry and a favorite of animal observers.NOTE: It’s recommended to take off the phone case when using the lens since it may cause unstability while shooting.
  • ★The kit is suitable for use on my phone?★:The lens kit works on 99% popular cell phones on the market. If the distance from the center of the camera(the phone has only one camera) or the main camera(two or more cameras) to any edge of your phone is less than 2.2cm, then the kit will work on your phone.How to know which is the main camera: block the camera one by one with the camera app on, the one you see a blockage there is the main camera.
  • ★Best Gift Choice & 100% Satisfaction★:A phone lens kit that will provide you an extraordinary experience to capture wonderful moments in your life. The kit is fully equipped and packed in a storage box (can be carried by hand), this lens kit would be a very nice gift choice.Your satisfaction is the most important thing for us. Don’t be hesitate. Thrill your family and friends with Bostionye phone lens right now!

That is why two slogans are both inadequate. Women hate dick pics overgeneralizes and erases people whose experiences differ. Women secretly like them is equally misleading because it treats a minority or context-specific reaction as retroactive consent for everyone else.

Consent is the dividing line

The distinction WIRED emphasized remains the clearest way to understand the issue:

Consensual sexting Unsolicited genital image
People have agreed, explicitly or through a clear shared exchange, to sexual image-sharing. One person introduces sexual imagery without giving the recipient a meaningful choice beforehand.
Each participant can pause, decline, or withdraw without being pressured. The recipient must deal with the sexual content before being able to decide whether to engage.
The image is part of a mutually understood relationship or conversation. The sender’s intention is used to stand in for the recipient’s permission.

Consent is therefore not a judgment about whether penises are inherently offensive or whether male nudity is inherently shameful. It is a question of whether the person receiving the sexual material agreed to be part of that interaction.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

The term cyberflashing is often used for the digital delivery of an unsolicited genital image. WIRED highlighted technologies such as AirDrop, where a person nearby may receive an image without having asked for it. The same consent problem can arise through dating apps, direct messages, social platforms, email, or any other channel. The medium changes; the underlying issue does not.

A sender’s claim that the image was intended to excite, flatter, flirt, or make someone laugh cannot erase the absence of consent. Intent may matter when researchers or courts analyze conduct, but it does not give the recipient an obligation to experience the image as erotic or harmless.

Why context and identity matter

Andrea Waling and Tinonee Pym’s qualitative analysis of social-media posts, digital-news coverage, comics, and blogs found several competing public framings of the dick pic. Some treated it as harassment or sexual violence. Others used humor and ridicule to defuse, criticize, or reclaim the experience. Still others presented genital-image sharing as playful or erotic.

These framings are not interchangeable. A comic making fun of an unsolicited image is not evidence that the image was welcome. A consensual exchange between partners is not evidence that a stranger’s image will be received in the same way. Cultural interpretation can explain how people talk about dick pics without determining whether a particular recipient consented.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

The research also cautions against treating heterosexual, cisgender norms as the universal model. The later reaction study included women of all sexual identities and gay or bisexual men. Queer and gay male communities may have different conventions around erotic image-sharing, while those conventions still depend on agreement between the people involved. A person’s sexual orientation does not create blanket permission to send or receive intimate images.

Relationship and power also matter. An image from a long-term partner, a new dating-app match, a stranger on public transit, a coworker, or someone with authority over the recipient can carry very different risks. The sender’s identity, the recipient’s expectations, the possibility of retaliation, and the ability to avoid future contact can all change the experience.

Rank #3
Phone Camera Lens Kit 10 in 1 for iPhone Samsung Pixel Android, 22X Telephoto Lens, 0.62X Super Wide Angle Lens&25X Macro Lens, 235° Fisheye,Kaleidoscopes, Starlight,Tripod,for Most Smartphone Black
  • ◆10-in-1 most complete mobile camera lens kit◆:Bostionye phone camera lens kit is perfect for exploring more advanced mobile photography and Videography.Includes 6 lenses:22 times telephoto lens,0.62 wide angle Lens, 25X Macro lens, 235°Fisheye lens,Kaleidoscopes, Starlight Filter.Auxiliary equipment:universal clip, tripod, eyecup and Bostionye storage bag。
  • ◆With unique features◆: 235° fisheye lens-create interesting and unique circular mysterious effect pictures. 25x macro lens-Alignment lens for shooting flowers, insects and other small objects (optimal shooting distance: 1 to 3 inches).0.62ultra wide-angle lens-capture a large field of view to get an amazing angle of view..Kaleidoscope lens: For example, if you shoot at a small angle, you will see another flower pattern.Starburst Lens: like"stars,"streaking outward from a central light source.
  • ◆High quality◆: Bostionye mobile phone lens kit: The professional HD lens adopts industrial-grade aluminum and advanced optical glass lens design, which can provide you with a clear lens and reduce glare and reflection. So you can take photos with amazing clarity and detail while being confident that they will last forever. Shooting artwork pictures by using your smartphones with our phone camera lens kit,enjoy the technical image effect.
  • ◆The kit is suitable for use on my phone?◆:The lens kit works on 99% popular cell phones on the market. If the distance from the center of the camera(the phone has only one camera) or the main camera(two or more cameras) to any edge of your phone is less than 2.2cm, then the kit will work on your phone.How to know which is the main camera: block the camera one by one with the camera app on, the one you see a blockage there is the main camera.
  • ◆Best Gift Choice & 100% Satisfaction◆:A phone lens kit that will provide you an extraordinary experience to capture wonderful moments in your life. The kit is fully equipped and packed in a storage box (can be carried by hand), this lens kit would be a very nice gift choice.Your satisfaction is the most important thing for us. You could still reach out to us even the return window of Amazon has been closed. Don’t be hesitate. Thrill your family and friends with Bostionye phone lens right now!

Gender norms help explain the double standard

WIRED quoted sociologist Andrea Waling’s argument that men’s bodies are often granted more public playfulness, while women’s nude images are more closely associated with shame, exposure, and risk. That difference shapes both the sending and the receiving of sexual images.

Rosemary Riccardelli’s work on teen sexting was also used to describe a gendered pattern in which boys’ image-sharing may be treated as relatively low-stakes while girls are taught to protect themselves against reputational and sexual consequences. This is useful cultural context, but the age-specific claims in the 2019 article came through expert reporting rather than a clearly identified prevalence study. They should not be repeated as a universal statistic about teenagers.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Gender norms can make the same act appear playful for one person and dangerous for another. They can also encourage men to interpret sexual attention as a reward and women to anticipate blame, exposure, or harassment. None of this means that every man sends, every woman fears, or every recipient reacts according to a binary script. It means that the social costs and perceived risks are not distributed evenly.

What newer studies add

A study of 347 Spanish women aged 18 to 30 examined unwanted dick pics as a form of sexual cyber-violence, including emotional impact and coping strategies. A separate 2025 study of 392 Spanish women examined reactions to unsolicited genital images in connection with sexism, social norms, power, and the relationship between recipient and sender.

These studies reinforce the importance of context and perceived power. They should not be treated as direct measurements of every population: both are geographically and demographically specific, and their methods and questions differ from the U.S. reaction study.

More broadly, the research base has grown beyond early questions about why men send images. Researchers now examine recipients’ emotional responses, gendered expectations, sexual cyber-violence, image-based sexual offending, cultural meaning, and the role of social norms. The field is larger than it was in 2019, but it remains too varied to support a single all-purpose percentage or psychological explanation.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

The law has changed—but not everywhere in the same way

The most significant legal development since WIRED’s article is in England and Wales. The Online Safety Act 2023 created a specific cyberflashing offense by inserting provisions into the Sexual Offences Act 2003. The Crown Prosecution Service describes the offense as sending photographs or films of genitals. The maximum penalty is up to two years’ imprisonment and/or a fine.

That is a statement about England and Wales, not a blanket rule for the United Kingdom. It should not be presented as the law in Scotland or Northern Ireland without separate verification, and it should not be presented as U.S. law. The New York City legislation discussed as a proposal in WIRED’s 2019 article is historical context, not a current universal legal baseline.

In the United States and elsewhere, rules may depend on the state or country, the recipient’s age, harassment or stalking laws, threats, coercion, workplace rules, platform policies, and the circumstances of the conduct. Anyone considering a report or legal action should check the law where the conduct occurred or seek advice from a qualified local service.

Rank #4
MIAO LAB 11 in 1 Phone Camera Lens Kit - Wide Angle Lens & Macro Lens+Fisheye Lens+ND32//CPL/Color Lens/Star+Kaleidoscope Lens for iPhone Samsung Sony and Most of Smartphone
  • 📷【11 IN 1 DETACHABLE LENS】:This perfect phone camera lens kit including ND32 filter,kaleidoscope lens,CPL filter,star filter,Fisheye Lens four Grad color lens(Blue, Gray, yellow,orange) for your daily photography use and make your photography more creative. 140°Super wide Angle Lens + Update MACRO Lens show you an wide angle view & a clear photo in detail from the target object.
  • 📷【Newly Designed Grad Color Lens】: Four color lens set can give you diversity of creativity. Perfect for changing the mood of a picture. Great for photographing the sky, the sunset, the rosy cloud, the lake water, Take your best coral reef tank photos yet! The smartphone lens filters optimize colors to make your beautiful aquarium colors
  • 📷【HIGH QUALITY CELL PHONE LENS】:Very professionally manufactured product made from aluminum,not cheap plastic,to increase the durability of the product,Put the clip install on phone camera and make sure the lens is aligned with phone camera lens. Shooting artwork pictures by using your smartphones with our phone camera lens kit,enjoy the technical image effect.
  • 📷【EASY TO USE】Universal detachable clamp design,Just clip on the camera lens with the clamp and make sure the lens is aligned with phone main camera lens. Just a few seconds then to make your phone act more like a professional camera.Let's our smart lens kit for cell phone bring you into a stunning fantasy world.
  • 📷【UNIVERSAL COMPATIBILITY & USE GUIDE】: Universal detachable clamp design,work with all kinds of smartphones and tablets, including iPhone 8,7,6,6 plus,6s,6s plus,Samsung Galaxy, iPad and other smartphone like Samsung, Huawei, Sony, LG, xiaomi and many others.

Images involving minors raise separate child-protection and criminal-law issues. They should never be treated as an ordinary adult sexting dispute, and people should not download, forward, or circulate them.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

What to do after receiving an unwanted image

  1. Do not feel obliged to reply. Silence, blocking, and ending the conversation are valid responses. You do not owe the sender an explanation or a more polite reaction.
  2. Preserve only the evidence you can safely keep. If you may report harassment, save relevant account details, dates, messages, or platform notifications. Avoid copying or forwarding the image unnecessarily.
  3. Use the platform’s reporting and blocking tools. Report the account or message under the closest available category, such as unwanted sexual content, harassment, or nonconsensual intimate imagery.
  4. Escalate when there is a wider threat. Repeated contact, blackmail, stalking, threats, workplace involvement, or distribution to others may warrant advice from a trusted support organization, the platform, an employer or school, or local law enforcement.
  5. Get support if the experience affected you. Discomfort, anger, fear, numbness, or confusion are all possible responses. The fact that some people find such images funny or arousing does not invalidate a recipient who experiences the contact as violating.

If you have sent an image without permission, the responsible response is to stop, not resend it, remove it where possible, and offer a brief apology without demanding reassurance. Explaining that you meant it as a compliment does not require the recipient to accept the contact or continue the conversation.

Further reading on the cultural debate

For readers who want the scholarly and cultural analysis behind the subject, Andrea Waling’s book on the cultural phenomenon of the dick pic, published by Routledge in 2023, examines the image’s public meanings, male body politics, erotic possibilities, and men’s lived experiences. It is cultural research, not a practical consent guide and not a substitute for legal advice.

What the research still cannot answer

The evidence remains limited in several important ways. Studies use different definitions of an unsolicited image, different samples, and different methods. Some ask participants about real experiences; others examine hypothetical scenarios or public discourse. Findings from U.S. women and gay or bisexual men, Spanish women aged 18 to 30, and qualitative analyses of media cannot be merged as though they describe one population.

Researchers still need better prevalence estimates across countries and platforms, longitudinal work on whether and why people continue sending unwanted images, more research with trans and nonbinary recipients and senders, and clearer evidence about what platform rules, education, reporting systems, and laws actually prevent harm. The effectiveness of the England-and-Wales offense is an important question that cannot be answered merely by noting that the law exists.

Free tools Windows power users keep installed

One-click scans. No signup required.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

That unfinished research does not create uncertainty about the basic ethical point. Consensual sexual image-sharing and unsolicited genital-image sending are different acts. People may interpret the latter through humor, desire, disgust, anger, or fear, but the recipient—not the sender’s presumed script—gets to determine whether the interaction was wanted.