Just Sam said they returned to busking in New York’s subway because they could not afford rent or food. They also said the return was embarrassing and far from what they had imagined after winning American Idol in 2020.
Why did Just Sam return to the subway?
Sam gave a direct financial reason in a 2023 interview with The Washington Post: “But I literally could not afford to pay my rent. I couldn’t afford to eat.” Videos of Sam singing in subway stations, with a donation box nearby, had circulated widely that spring.
Before Idol, Sam had busked in New York’s subway stations since they were young. They said they had imagined returning one day for fun or nostalgia, not because they needed the income. “If I ever went back to the trains, I didn’t expect it to be something that I had to do. I felt like it would be something that I did for fun, you know, relive an old moment or memory, you know?” Sam told the Post.
What happened after Sam won American Idol?
A win during the pandemic
Sam won Season 18 in May 2020. The pandemic shaped the finale: finalists performed remotely, and Sam celebrated the result from a Los Angeles hotel room while seeing their grandmother on an iPad. The show had introduced Sam as a subway singer who helped support their grandmother.
Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware matchWindows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstall#1 Best Overall
- One right-handed Fender California Debut Redondo acoustic guitar – a perfect beginner guitar for all ages
- Designed by the most trusted name in guitar and backed by a 75-year legacy of quality and craftsmanship
- This beginner guitar comes with a 30-day subscription to Fender Play that includes lessons with thousands of instructional videos to build your skills by playing the songs you love, all with no additional cost
- The California Debut Redondo Series Acoustic Guitar features the iconic 6-in-line Fender headstock shape and dreadnought body shape with a reslient laminate construction for durability
- The easy to play "C" - shaped neck, walnut fingerboard and light weight all-laminate body allow for a smooth and comfortable playing feel, and the sealed-gear tuning machines allow for accurate tuning, with a walnut bridge for optimal tone production
A disrupted recording launch
After the win, Sam received a recording deal connected with Hollywood Records and 19 Recordings. Sam told the Post that pandemic conditions delayed studio work and slowed the momentum of a typical winner’s launch. The Post reported that Sam parted ways with the labels less than a year after the win.
The account does not establish a definitive reason for the end of the arrangement. Sam did not explain in detail what went wrong with the label, and their management team declined to clarify the agreement, citing nondisclosure concerns. The labels and production company did not provide on-record comment to the Post.
Rank #2
- With a combination of reliable Fender quality, player-friendly features and attractive aesthetics, the all-new California Debut is a value-packed option for today’s acoustic player
- Designed for beginner's, featuring a durable all-laminate body crafted with premium tonewoods, and an easy-to-play “C”-shape neck with tilt-back 6-in-line headstock. With a walnut fingerboard for a smooth and comfortable playing feel.
- Further details include Dreadnought body shape, sealed-gear tuning machines for accurate tuning, a walnut bridge for optimal tone production, a smooth satin finish, and body and neck binding for added durability
- The CA Debut series packs premium Fender quality into an affordable beginner friendly acoustic guitar. The CA Debut series also ships with a free 30-day subscription to Fender Play & Fender Tune, so you can start learning from the comfort of your home the second you unpack your new guitar!
- 2-Year Limited Warranty: Fender guitars are built with unmatched quality, down to the last screw- which is why Fender warrants this Fender acoustic guitar to be free from defects in materials and workmanship for two (2) years from original purchase
Did Sam blame American Idol?
No. Sam said they did not blame the show, its producers, or its judges for their financial hardship, and expressed gratitude for the experience: “I’m grateful for them. They changed my life forever,” Sam said. “Even though it’s not in the way I expected.”
The Post reported that recent Idol winner contracts had paid $125,000 at the win and another $125,000 on delivery of an album, for a reported total of $250,000. That figure was general context about recent contracts, not confirmation of Sam’s specific contract or earnings.
Recommended Free Tools
Rank #3
- Complete Beginner Guitar Pack - Everything needed for starters is included, just unbox & play. The bundle includes Moukey 41” acoustic guitar, chord poster, 3mm padded gig bag, tuner, strap, capo, strings and picks. A decent gift for children, friends and family.
- Ideal for Beginner - With cutaway design, Moukey 41” acoustic guitar is easy for starter to learn. Dreadnought body provides a full and vibrant tone, suited for all styles of music. The precise position marks at 3th, 5th, 7th, 9th, 12th 15th and 17th frets on neck and top of fingerboard help the starters to learn conveniently.
- Come with Chord Poster - The ultimate beginner-friendly guitar chord poster shows the most commonly used chords, enabling starters to memorize fretboard and play chords on the first day.
- Exquisite Workmanship - Quality basswood body, Okoume neck, smooth fingerboard, and non--scratching frets enable Moukey acustica guitarra to be played comfortably for a long time. 2 strap pegs allow you to attach the strap easily.
- Stay in Tune - Constructed with 1:14 enclosed copper tuning machines, Moukey full size guitar can be tuned finely and smoothly without slipping. Along with hard bridge saddle and bone nut, Moukey guitarra acustica is easy to tune and hold tune after first tune-up of strings.
How did American Idol respond to Sam’s return?
On April 28, 2024, Sam returned to the show to perform Whitney Houston’s “One Moment in Time.” The performance had a full stage production and confetti—a contrast with the remote 2020 finale. Sam said producers told them they wanted to give them a moment they had missed the first time around.
Executive producer and showrunner Megan Wolflick said she had wanted to bring Sam back when the timing worked. “We were super, super happy to welcome them back with open arms and give them the full treatment in the gown and the makeup. And the confetti was really important because they never got confetti,” Wolflick told the Post. Sam speculated that media attention and the response from fans helped lead to the invitation, while Wolflick described the producers’ own interest in welcoming them back.
Rank #4
- Perfect beginner guitar: Designed for students and teens who are just getting started. This 38-inch, right-handed, acoustic guitar features all the bells and whistles. Designed with 18 smooth frets, 6 pre-installed steel strings, and an easy to hold neck.
- Complete beginner kit: This all-in-one entry-level guitar bundle includes a 38-inch acoustic guitar, carrying bag, 3 picks (assorted colors), shoulder strap, extra strings, and 4 months of free app-based lessons (iOS or Android). The App features thousands of songs, step-by-step lessons for all skill levels, and a built-in digital tuner for easy tuning anywhere.
- Superior-grade tonewoods: Top, back, and sides are crafted from basswood for versatility and warmth, with a high-gloss finish. Whether playing soft or loud, strumming or flatpicking, this guitar remains responsive and retains its tonal integrity. This guitar is built to last.
- Incredible sound: Perfect for musicians-in-the-making, this beginner acoustic guitar features an impressive tone, bright sound, and standout projection. It's waiting to be heard.
- 38-inch beginner guitar: Measuring 38" (L) x 14" (W) x 3.25" (H), this beginner guitar delivers the timeless look and sound of a traditional acoustic guitar. Low string action helps reduce finger fatigue for easier playing and improved comfort while learning. Note: New strings may arrive out of tune, which is normal. As the strings stretch with use, the guitar will hold tuning better over time.
In that 2024 follow-up, Sam said: “I know that this is not the end of my story.” The Post also reported at the time that Sam was working with CrowdMGMT and writing and recording new music; those are historical details, not confirmation of their current arrangements or activity.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
