The BBC says the Match of the Day (MOTD) programme editor makes the final decision on the running order, with input from the presenter and pundits. Goals and match quality matter, but so do the consequences of a result and the point in the season. The BBC’s account explains the process; it does not independently prove that every decision is free of bias.
Who decides the Match of the Day running order?
According to the BBC’s explainer published on 24 January 2025 and updated 14 August 2025, the programme editor has the final say. The editor watches the matches alongside the presenter and pundits, and they discuss the order; the final responsibility rests with the editor.
Each Premier League match also has an assigned producer who oversees its television edit. The BBC says each edit has a fixed duration, with the first match generally receiving the longest slot. How much studio analysis a game gets usually depends on where it appears in the running order. The BBC also says the team speaks to the Premier League before the programme to clarify VAR decisions and bookings, informing the discussion on the show.
What determines which match goes first?
The BBC says the editor considers the action and sporting context rather than applying a single rule such as “the most goals go first.” The main considerations it identifies are:
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →#1 Best Overall
- Goals and match quality: A high-scoring or especially compelling game is often a strong candidate to lead.
- What the result means: A match affecting the title race, European places or relegation can carry more weight than its scoreline alone suggests.
- Contentious moments: Controversial VAR or penalty decisions can make a game more significant for the programme.
- Where the season stands: The importance of a result can grow as a competition approaches its decisive stages.
The balance changes from week to week. A goalless draw may ordinarily rank below a game full of goals, but if it has major consequences late in the season, it could be a stronger opening choice. The BBC describes the process as starting afresh each week: “Each week the programme editor will start with a blank canvas, and the order in which the matches are shown are on merit of the day’s action alone.”
Does the most exciting match always lead?
No. A lively game often opens the programme, but the BBC’s stated criteria also include sporting stakes and consequential incidents. That means a match can lead because of what its result changes, even if another fixture produced more goals or more continuous action.
Rank #2
The running order also affects the programme’s pacing: the first match is generally the longest, while the amount of studio analysis usually varies according to a match’s position. Former host Gary Lineker described the audience balance this creates in a BBC Sport interview published 16 August 2017: “Sometimes the absolute football anoraks will want more analysis but the people that just get their little football fix from Match of the Day want the action – so you have got to strike a balance somewhere in the middle.” That is Lineker’s description of audience needs, not a formal rule for ranking games.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Is MOTD biased towards big clubs?
The available evidence does not establish that the running order is biased towards big clubs, but it also does not amount to an independent audit proving that bias never occurs. The BBC explains its stated editorial method; testing whether it is applied consistently would require evidence beyond that explanation.
The BBC’s summary of its 2023–24 placement graphic says mid-table teams tended to appear later on average, while teams chasing European places or fighting relegation tended to appear earlier. That pattern is compatible with the BBC’s emphasis on the consequences of results. However, the source text does not give the graphic’s underlying values, so it cannot show how large the differences were or independently verify why they occurred.
There is also a reason running-order complaints can feel personal. In the same 2017 interview, Lineker said: “In all the years of criticism on social media about the running order, I have never had anyone complaining about the treatment of a team different to the one that they support – and you get it about all of them!” That is his observation about the complaints he encountered, not a measurement of all fan reactions or proof that preferential treatment is impossible.
Quick Recap
What can be concluded from the evidence?
- The BBC says the programme editor makes the final call after discussion with the presenter and pundits.
- Its stated criteria include goals, match quality, the importance of results, contentious decisions and the stage of the season.
- A high-scoring game may lead, but it is not guaranteed to: a match with greater consequences can take precedence.
- The BBC’s account describes its process and a 2023–24 placement pattern; the underlying values and an independent assessment of individual decisions are not provided in the cited text.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
