The “Hail Hydra” ending of Captain America: Steve Rogers #1 was a deliberately startling comic-book cliffhanger—not proof that Steve Rogers had permanently become a villain. In his May 25, 2016 opinion piece, io9 writer James Whitbrook argued that readers were overreacting to the reveal’s dramatic framing. Marvel later developed the premise into the multi-issue Secret Empire story, attributing Steve’s altered history to the Cosmic Cube.
What was the Captain America reveal?
At the end of Captain America: Steve Rogers #1, Steve appears to be secretly aligned with Hydra. The issue interweaves a present-day story about Steve returning to action as Captain America with a 1926 framing story involving his mother, Sarah, and Hydra’s early days. The final-page implication—that Steve has been a Hydra agent all along—collided with the familiar image of Captain America as a heroic figure.
Whitbrook’s article described the moment sarcastically as “SHOCKING NEWS: Steven Rogers has secretly been a Hydra Agent all along!” The line captures his impatience with the cliffhanger’s sensational presentation; it is commentary, not a neutral Marvel description. Whitbrook also noted that pre-publication coverage had already spoiled the twist, which affected how the reveal landed for readers who had seen that coverage.
Why did Whitbrook say readers should stop freaking out?
Whitbrook’s central point was about how to read a comic-book cliffhanger: a shocking change in a character’s apparent status quo is not, by itself, evidence that the character has been permanently transformed. He treated the “Hail Hydra” moment as an outrageous hook rather than a reason to conclude that Captain America’s established identity had simply vanished.
#1 Best Overall
- 12-Inch scale Captain America figure – Imagine Captain America launching his star-spangled shield into battle alongside fellow Avengers with this 12-inch-scale Captain America figure, inspired by Avengers: Endgame
- Connect Titan hero power FX launcher (not included) for sounds and phrases – connect the Titan hero power FX launcher (not included) to the action figure’s arm port to activate sounds and phrases inspired by the Marvel movie and fire projectiles
- Marvel movie-inspired design – fans can imagine the action-packed scenes of the Marvel universe with this Captain America figure, inspired by the Avengers: Endgame movie
- Compatible with titan hero power FX launcher (not included) – connect to Titan hero series and Titan hero power FX figures (each sold separately) for sounds and phrases from the Avengers movies
- Look for other Marvel Avengers toys - be on the lookout for other Marvel Avenger figures and gear to imagine forming a team of Avengers! Additional products each sold separately. Subject to availability
That was Whitbrook’s opinion when he wrote on May 25, 2016—not a statement of Marvel’s intent, and not a reliable prediction about how soon the story would be resolved. The reveal was fictional, but it was designed to provoke a strong reaction by setting Steve’s implied allegiance against his heroic legacy.
How did Marvel develop the twist?
Marvel did not leave the premise as a single-issue tease. Its later catalog material connects the Hydra reveal to Secret Empire, a larger event storyline. Marvel’s paperback synopsis says, “The Cosmic Cube has remade the world’s greatest hero into a secret true believer in the cause of Hydra.” That provides Marvel’s later explanation for the altered history; the catalog synopsis alone does not establish every detail of the story’s mechanics or outcome.
Rank #2
- MARVEL STUDIOS’ AVENGERS: ENDGAME: This collectible Marvel figure is inspired by Captain America’s appearance in the iconic Avengers: Endgame film -- a great gift for adult collectors and fans ages 14 and up
- PREMIUM DECO & DESIGN: Marvel fans and collectors can display this 6 inch action figure (15 cm) in their Marvel action figure collections
- CHARACTER-INSPIRED ACCESSORIES: This officially licensed figure comes with 4 accessories, including Captain America’s signature shield, a set of alternate hands, and an alternate portrait head
- DISPLAY-WORTHY ARTICULATION: This collectible features over 20 points of articulation with fully poseable head, arms, and legs for dynamic poses on your shelf
- WINDOW BOX PACKAGING: Display your Marvel fandom on your shelf with collectible window box packaging
The continuity question was made explicit in Captain America: Steve Rogers #13, published March 8, 2017. Marvel’s listing asks: “If Captain America has been an agent of Hydra since childhood, how did he fight WWII on the side of the Allies?” The publisher says the issue reveals the secret story. That question shows why the premise mattered beyond the final-page shock: it put Steve’s wartime history and apparent allegiance in conflict.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Where can you read the larger story?
Marvel’s Secret Empire trade paperback collects the core event and related material. Its listed contents are:
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsRank #3
- LARGE-SCALE MARVEL ACTION FIGURE: This large-scale Captain America toy features a classic design inspired by the Marvel comics, and stands 11.5-inches (29.2 cm) tall
- ICONIC CHARACTERS: Marvel Titan Series Avengers Super Hero action figures feature iconic fan-favorite characters, including Iron Man and Captain America
- POSEABLE FIGURE: Marvel Titan Series Avengers toys feature 11 points of articulation, so boys and girls can pose them for world-saving adventures they imagine
- CHARACTER-INSPIRED ACCESSORY: The Titan Series Captain America figure comes with a detachable shield accessory, so kids can imagine patriotic, vibranium-powered battles
- COLLECTIBLE PACKAGING: This Marvel Captain America action figure comes in a window box package that features classic Marvel design, which will look awesome on display
- Secret Empire #0–10 and Secret Empire: Omega
- Captain America (2017) #25
- Material from Free Comic Book Day 2017
Marvel also lists a hardcover edition and provides an event reading list with core issues and tie-ins. The collected paperback is a straightforward way to read the larger story tied to the reveal; the reading list is useful if you want the broader issue sequence. Current price and availability can vary.
Sources: James Whitbrook’s May 25, 2016 io9/Gizmodo article; Marvel’s listings for Captain America: Steve Rogers #13 and the Secret Empire trade paperback; and Marvel’s Secret Empire event reading list.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Imagine leaping into adventure with Avengers figures, vehicles, and roleplay items inspired by the Marvel Universe
- Includes Iron Man, Captain America, Black Panther and Iron Spider
- Connect the Titan Hero Power FX Pack (not included) to operate the figures
Rank #4
- High quality toys for children all ages
- Made using safe materials
- Tested for quality and durability
- Incredible Captain America figure
- 12 inches tall
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
