In the Italy fan-crowd video covered by PerthNow, Anne Hathaway reportedly declined to take individual photos with everyone, apologized, and offered to stand and wave so the group could take pictures. Some viewers called her manner rude or condescending; others defended her decision not to make an exception in a large crowd. The footage does not establish a single agreed-upon verdict about her behavior.
What happened in the Italy video?
PerthNow’s 3 February 2024 account describes fans gathered around Hathaway’s car in Italy, asking for photos and autographs. As the crowd pressed in, she reportedly said, “Calma, calma,” then explained that she could not take photos with everyone. She offered an alternative: “I cannot take photos with everyone but I will stand here and wave if you would like to take a photo.”
PerthNow also reports that Hathaway apologized—“Mi dispiace, (I’m sorry), but I want you to have something”—and thanked people for understanding and waiting. When a fan asked again, she reportedly explained that if she took a photo with that person, she would have to take one with everyone, and there were too many people. These quotations reflect PerthNow’s rendering of the exchange; the available reporting does not provide an independently verified transcript. PerthNow’s report
Was Anne Hathaway rude to her fans?
There is no objective verdict on tone in the reports. PerthNow quoted some viewers describing Hathaway as condescending or fake-polite, while another defended her on the grounds that celebrities are not obliged to engage with every fan. The same account includes both her refusal to take individual pictures for the whole crowd and her offer to wave for group photos.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →That combination can be read differently: some viewers may focus on how the refusal sounded, while others may see a practical boundary and an attempt to offer something to the group. The footage and reported remarks do not establish Hathaway’s intent, and the reactions cited in coverage should not be treated as a consensus among viewers.
Is this the same video as the London fan interaction?
No. A separate clip followed the 2023 British Fashion Awards in London. The Independent reported that, hours after the 4 December event, Hathaway got out of a car as fans approached. In that video, she appeared to signal for them to stop advancing and to say she would come to them when she was ready. The Independent reported that the clip had more than six million views as of 7 December 2023. The Independent’s account
The Daily Dot also covered a London fan video, identifying it as a silent TikTok posted by @scottish969. The outlet reported that TikTok creator Jackie (@tismejackieg), whom it described as deaf, lip-read Hathaway as greeting fans, asking them not to move, and saying she would come to them; Jackie also posted a duet. That is the creator’s interpretation of silent footage, not an official transcript. The Daily Dot cited 16 million views but did not make clear when that count was measured. Its account described positive reactions to Hathaway’s request that fans stay in place while she approached. The Daily Dot’s report
The London coverage described more supportive audience reactions, including praise for politeness and boundary-setting. That contrast does not show that the two clips were identical or that audiences reacted uniformly across platforms.
Rank #3
When was the Italy footage recorded?
The precise recording date is unclear in the available reports. PerthNow described the Italy crowd video as footage from 2023, while iHeart’s 4 February 2024 item described an old 2022 recording at a Valentino fashion show in Italy. The reporting does not conclusively establish whether those descriptions refer to the same recording, so a specific filming year should not be stated as settled. iHeart’s account
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
