DC’s Harley Quinn Fartacular: Silent Butt Deadly #1 became controversial because its deliberately crude scratch-and-sniff fart humor prompted sharply different readings: some people saw juvenile gross-out comedy, while some commenters called it fetish-oriented. Reviews also disagreed about whether the jokes had a more pointed theme about shame and women’s bodies. Separately, online discussion included homophobic attacks on Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy’s relationship. The available coverage documents these reactions, but does not establish how common they were.
What is Harley Quinn: Silent Butt Deadly?
The full title is Harley Quinn Fartacular: Silent Butt Deadly #1, a DC comic released March 26, 2025. DC lists it as a 40-page issue rated Teen, written by Joanne Starer, with art and cover by Brandt & Stein. DC’s official issue listing identifies it as a comic, not a documentary or an accidental title.
The premise is intentionally built around fart jokes. DC’s solicitation advertises “real artificial rub ’n’ smell farts” and jokes about the “highest concentration of gas per page (GPP) ever committed to print.” That record-style claim is promotional humor, not a verified statistic. The solicitation also cautions readers who are grossed out by farts. The DC Connect 56 solicitation makes the intended gross-out gimmick explicit.
Why did the comic draw criticism?
Some readers interpreted the premise as fetish content
Popverse’s January 30, 2025 report records commenters describing the announced comic as fetish-oriented. That is a reader interpretation of the subject matter; the available sources do not establish that the creators intended it that way or provide a named creator’s explanation of the controversy. Popverse’s report documents examples of comments, not a representative survey.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →#1 Best Overall
- Written by Joanne Starer
- Illustrated by Ted Brandt, Ro Stein
Others saw a crude gag, not a deeper statement
There is a straightforward reason the issue could strike readers as juvenile or off-putting: the publisher itself foregrounded fart jokes and a scratch-and-sniff feature. Finding that premise excessive does not require accepting the claim that it was created for fetish appeal. The marketing establishes the joke’s deliberate crudeness, but it cannot prove private creator motives.
Reviews disagreed about whether the humor carried a theme
GeekDad describes a story in which Poison Ivy farts while gardening, Harley reacts, and Ivy becomes upset after Harley jokes about it. Harley then tries to win her back. The review treats the issue as an April Fools special and questions whether an extended run of fart jokes works. GeekDad’s review presents that skeptical response.
AIPT reads the premise more favorably, interpreting the comic as challenging shame attached to women’s bodily functions. AIPT’s review offers that thematic reading; it is an interpretation, not a confirmed statement of authorial intent. Together, the reviews show why the same gag could register as either repetitive gross-out humor or a provocation about embarrassment and bodily shame.
How did Harley and Ivy’s relationship enter the discussion?
Popverse also reports homophobic comments directed at Harley and Poison Ivy’s relationship. Those attacks are distinct from criticism that the comic’s fart humor was childish, distasteful, or fetish-coded. The report shows that such remarks appeared in the discussion; it does not establish that they were the dominant reaction or explain how widespread they were.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Rank #3
- High quality authentic replica made by The Noble Collection.
- Made of hardwood.
- Measures 31.5 inches in length.
- Officially authorized by Warner Brothers and DC Comics.
What the controversy does—and does not—show
- Established: DC deliberately promoted a fart-centered comic with an artificial scratch-and-sniff gimmick.
- Established: Some commenters called the premise fetish-oriented, while reviews differed over its comedy and possible body-shame theme.
- Also reported: Some online remarks attacked Harley and Ivy’s relationship with homophobic language.
- Not established: The prevalence of any reaction, a measurable audience consensus, or a named creator’s account of the controversy.
So the title became controversial less because its premise was ambiguous than because readers disagreed over what that premise meant—and because some discussion crossed from criticism of the comic into attacks on its queer relationship.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- This Harley Quinn duck figure is a must-have for fans of DC Comics merchandise and pop culture collectibles.
- Packaged in an eco-friendly cardboard box featuring the DC Comics logo, ideal for display.
- Collect characters from movies, games, bands, and TV shows, reimagined as cosplaying duck figures.
- Approximately 9 cm (3.54 inches) tall outside of packaging, a great size for your shelf, desk, or car dashboard.
- Stand out with these fun, collectible cosplaying ducks - perfect for adding a special twist to jeep ducking.
Rank #4
- HARLEY QUINN PLUSH: Go absolutely batty for the DC Harley Quinn Plush
- PRINTED DESIGN: Printed design features Harley's jumpsuit and face paint
- COLLECT MORE: Celebrate the rich history of DC by collecting more DC Plush
- OFFICIAL PRODUCT Officially licensed Harley Quinn product from Jazwares
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
