Tony Hinchcliffe: What to Know After the 2024 Trump Rally Controversy

Tony Hinchcliffe is a Youngstown, Ohio-raised stand-up comedian known for roast comedy, the podcast Kill Tony and appearances on Comedy Central roasts. His October 27, 2024 appearance at Donald Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally drew national attention after a joke about Puerto Rico and other remarks prompted condemnation. The Trump campaign publicly disavowed the Puerto Rico joke, while Hinchcliffe rejected the criticism rather than apologizing.

Who Tony Hinchcliffe is

Hinchcliffe grew up in Youngstown, Ohio, and moved to Los Angeles in 2007. The Washington Post reported that he has described comedy as his “only escape” and recalled sleeping in the back of his car in Los Angeles early in his career. His work centers on roast comedy: sharp, deliberately provocative jokes aimed at a person, group or situation.

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		Comedy Classics [DVD]	$7.85	Buy on Amazon
2		Comedy Triple Play Collection [DVD]	$45.25	Buy on Amazon

What he said at the Madison Square Garden rally

Trump’s rally took place on October 27, 2024, one week before the presidential election. Hinchcliffe was one of nearly 30 warm-up speakers. C-SPAN’s full recording is the primary audiovisual record of the event; the Associated Press reported that his set received the most attention because of racist and lewd material.

The line that spread most widely was:

“I don’t know if you guys know this, but there’s literally a floating island of garbage in the middle of the ocean right now. I think it’s called Puerto Rico.”

×

What’s actually slowing this PC down?

Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.

Junk files & broken settingsFree fix →System errors & instabilityFree fix →Outdated driversFree fix →Crashes & glitchesFree fix →

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

#1 Best Overall

Comedy Classics [DVD]

$7.85

Buy on Amazon

The Washington Post reported that the set also included jokes about immigrants and Latinos, a racist stereotype involving Black people, and jokes about Palestinians and Jewish people in the context of the Israel-Gaza war. These were remarks by a comedian performing at a campaign event, not an announcement of Trump policy.

Why the Trump campaign distanced itself

The campaign’s response was unusually direct. Senior adviser Danielle Alvarez said, “This joke does not reflect the views of President Trump or the campaign.” The statement separated the campaign from Hinchcliffe’s performance instead of treating the set as an expression of its platform.

Did Hinchcliffe apologize?

In the coverage of the rally controversy, Hinchcliffe did not issue an apology. On X, he said the joke had been taken out of context, accused critics of having “no sense of humor,” and said that he loves Puerto Rico and vacations there. Those comments defended his intent but did not retract the remark.

What happened in the earlier Peng Dang controversy?

In 2021, at an Austin performance, Hinchcliffe used a racial slur against comedian Peng Dang, according to the Associated Press and The Washington Post. WME dropped him and scheduled performances were canceled. The reporting says he did not apologize; an earlier defense quoted by AP was, “I knew that what I had done was not wrong.” The documented consequences establish agency and booking losses, but not a broader legal or industry blacklist.

Rank #2

Comedy Triple Play Collection [DVD]

$45.25

Buy on Amazon

How politicians and Puerto Rican figures responded

Republican Sen. Rick Scott said the joke “bombed for a reason” and praised Puerto Ricans. Republican Rep. María Elvira Salazar called it racist and said it did not represent Republican values. Democratic figures including Tim Walz and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez also condemned the comment.

Puerto Rican entertainer Ricky Martin posted, “This is what they think of us. Vote for @kamalaharris.” When the reactions were reported in 2024, The Washington Post noted that Martin had more than 18 million Instagram followers and Bad Bunny more than 45 million. Those were time-specific audience figures, not current counts.

What is Kill Tony?

Kill Tony is a live comedy podcast built around short auditions. Professional and amateur comedians perform for 60 seconds, then a judging panel critiques the set and interviews the performer. The Washington Post reported almost 1.9 million YouTube subscribers for the show in 2024.

The format helps explain Hinchcliffe’s public identity: he is associated with rapid-fire jokes, roast-style criticism and intentionally abrasive material. That context describes his comedic approach; it does not remove the political consequences of delivering those jokes at a presidential campaign rally.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

Comedy Classics [DVD]

$7.85

Bestseller No. 2

Comedy Triple Play Collection [DVD]

$45.25

What the controversy establishes—and what it does not

• Hinchcliffe made the Puerto Rico “floating island of garbage” joke and other offensive remarks at Trump’s October 27, 2024 rally.
• The Trump campaign publicly said the Puerto Rico joke did not represent Trump or the campaign.
• Hinchcliffe defended the joke and did not apologize in the sourced coverage.
• The episode followed a separately reported 2021 controversy involving Peng Dang, professional cancellations and no apology.
• The remarks should be understood as a comedian’s performance at a political event, not as an official statement of campaign policy.

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.