“After Hours,” the September 19, 2024 premiere of HBO’s The Penguin, turns Gotham’s criminal succession crisis into a close study of Oz Cobb’s wounded pride and ruthless ambition. Colin Farrell gives the hour an arresting center, while Sofia Falcone’s suspicion supplies the pressure that makes Oz’s first move feel dangerous.
What happens in “After Hours”?
Spoilers for the episode follow.
Set after the seawall disaster in The Batman, the premiere finds Gotham still damaged and the criminal order unsettled by crime boss Carmine Falcone’s death. Oz Cobb sees an opening. When Carmine’s son Alberto mocks Oz for skimming from the family business, Oz kills him. He then recruits Victor Aguilar, a vulnerable young man he catches near his car, to help dispose of the body.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
The Penguin: The Complete First Season (Blu-ray) | $18.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
![The Penguin [Steelbook] [4K UHD] [2024] [Blu-ray] [Region Free]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41jsQnnBf4L._SL160_.jpg)
|
The Penguin [Steelbook] [4K UHD] [2024] [Blu-ray] [Region Free] | $57.64 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
![The Penguin [Blu-ray] [2024] [Region Free]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51URXfhMt2L._SL160_.jpg)
|
The Penguin [Blu-ray] [2024] [Region Free] | $35.06 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
The Penguin Blu-ray | Colin Farrell | $33.78 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
![Penguins of Madagascar [Blu-ray]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61z7OL3-CBL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Penguins of Madagascar [Blu-ray] | $8.88 | Buy on Amazon |
Oz tries to turn the murder into a political advantage by framing rival boss Salvatore Maroni and stirring conflict between the families. But Sofia Falcone, newly returned from Arkham, questions him about her brother. Her suspicion threatens to expose the lie at the center of Oz’s bid for power.
Does the premiere make Oz compelling?
Yes—chiefly because the episode treats Oz’s ambition as something more personal than a climb up a crime-family ladder. Alberto’s insult is the immediate trigger for murder, and the abruptness matters: Oz’s talk of neighborhood loyalty and old-school respect cannot disguise how quickly humiliation turns into violence. His first move toward power is not a master plan so much as an impulsive act he must learn to exploit.
#1 Best Overall
That tension gives Colin Farrell room to make Oz both watchable and unsettling. He can be socially nimble when he needs someone’s confidence, but the performance keeps a sense of grievance just beneath the performance. The showrunner has described the intention as planting signs of “something a little bit more disturbing” in Oz’s psychology, as reported by Sky. The premiere’s strongest character idea is that Oz’s charm and calculation do not cancel out his volatility; they help him put it to use.
Victor is more than a convenient recruit
Oz’s decision to involve Victor gives the episode a revealing second relationship. Victor’s stutter and precarious position seem to register with Oz, who recognizes a young man with limited options—and sees someone he can shape. Rhenzy Feliz, who plays Victor, described the connection as Oz understanding that Victor “maybe hasn’t been given many chances in life,” in Sky’s episode-related interview coverage.
Rank #2
The dynamic is uneasy precisely because it can be read as both recognition and exploitation. Oz offers Victor a place in his orbit, but that invitation begins with helping conceal a killing. Sky also reports Farrell’s description of their relationship as “Teacher/student, Master/mentor.” The premiere does not settle how much genuine attachment Oz can offer; it makes the imbalance between them part of the hook.
How do Sofia and Gotham shape the crime story?
Sofia Falcone is the premiere’s most immediate counterweight to Oz. He approaches the crisis through improvisation, charm, and lies; Sofia brings family authority and personal suspicion to the same problem. Her questions make the murder more than a secret Oz can bury. They create an active threat from someone who knows the family world he is trying to manipulate.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteRank #3
- The Penguin
Gotham also gives the familiar succession plot a damaged civic backdrop. The post-flood city feels unstable, and Carmine’s death leaves a vacuum rather than a clean handover. That context connects the series to The Batman without requiring the premiere to spend all its energy on franchise explanation. Apple TV presents the show as the next chapter in The Batman saga and describes this episode as Oz moving to fill the power vacuum after Carmine’s death.
For viewers who enjoy grounded mob stories, the episode’s central mechanics are legible: a killing, a cover-up, rival factions, and a vulnerable recruit. The comic-book setting adds atmosphere and scale, but the character conflict—not Batman lore—is what drives the hour. The setup is accessible without treating prior Gotham context as the main attraction.
Rank #4
- Blu-ray Movies, Blu-ray TV Shows
Do the performances and visual style carry the setup?
The cast and the episode’s visual approach are major strengths. Farrell anchors the hour, while Cristin Milioti gives Sofia an alertness that makes her scenes with Oz feel like a contest rather than exposition. Feliz provides a contrasting vulnerability in Victor, whose presence brings out both Oz’s appetite for control and his capacity to notice another person’s weakness.
Craig Zobel’s direction gives the story a dark, deliberate crime-drama texture, with Gotham’s damaged setting reinforcing the sense that the old order has already broken. Rotten Tomatoes’ critic excerpts for the episode highlight its eye-catching look and dark humor. The humor helps keep Oz’s flamboyance from turning the hour into unrelieved grimness, though it also sharpens the contrast between his showmanship and the violence he commits.
Best Value
- Blu-Ray + DVD + Digital HD
- Special Features: Top-Secret Guide to Becoming an Elite Agent / "He Is Dave" Music Video / Flipper Slap Shake Waddle and Roll / "Celebrate" Music Video by Pitbull / Do the Penguin Shake with tWitch / Deleted Scenes / Global Flight Plan / Cheezy Dibbles Ad / World of DreamWorks Animation / Gallery
Where does the episode’s storytelling divide opinion?
The premiere’s setup is clear and its character dynamics are promising, but the distinction between boldness and subtlety is not always in its favor. Oz’s murder, recruitment of Victor, and attempt to redirect suspicion establish the plot efficiently; the larger question is whether the series will deepen those ideas or keep returning to broad signals about power, cruelty, and status.
Critical response reflects that split. Rotten Tomatoes displayed a 100% Tomatometer from 15 critic reviews when accessed on October 8, 2026; that is a changeable aggregator snapshot, not a measure of the episode’s objective quality. TIME’s September 19, 2024 review of the series praised its immersive production design and acting while criticizing what it saw as broad dialogue, simplistic themes, and repetitive plotting. TIME’s assessment concerns the series, not this episode alone, but it points to a real risk in the premiere’s approach: if the characters’ contradictions are not developed, the atmosphere may end up doing more work than the writing.
“After Hours” is a strong invitation rather than a complete statement. It establishes an unstable antihero, a consequential bond with Victor, and a credible threat in Sofia. Whether that foundation becomes a layered crime saga depends on what follows, but the premiere gives viewers enough tension and performance to make the next move worth watching.
Quick Recap
Episode details
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Series and episode | The Penguin, season 1, episode 1: “After Hours” |
| Air date | September 19, 2024, according to Rotten Tomatoes |
| Director | Craig Zobel |
| Writer | Lauren LeFranc |
| Apple TV catalog duration | 1 hour 6 minutes |
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
