Recommended Free Tools
Norm Macdonald’s most notorious O.J. Simpson jokes on Saturday Night Live were a trial-era gag about a “lucky stabbing hat,” his post-acquittal declaration that “Murder is legal in the state of California,” and a 1997 joke about a restaurant dividing diners into “Murderer” and “Non-Murderer” sections. Their controversy came from treating a double-murder case—and questions of guilt, evidence and acquittal—as material for blunt comedy. No source establishes an objective ranking, and the jokes’ connection to Macdonald’s eventual removal from Weekend Update remains disputed.
The O.J. Simpson jokes that made Norm Macdonald notorious
Macdonald took over Weekend Update in 1994 and returned to the Simpson case in jokes that moved from trial coverage to the aftermath of the acquittal. The three most prominent examples differ in timing and target:
![Saturday Night Live 50th Anniversary Collection: Seasons One - Five [DVD]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41+XakhOIGL._SL160_.jpg)
| Joke | Context and target | Why it stood out |
|---|---|---|
| “That’s my lucky stabbing hat.” | During closing-argument coverage, Macdonald imagined Simpson objecting as Johnnie Cochran tried on a knit cap prosecutors said Simpson had worn. | It turned an item presented as evidence in a double-murder trial into a direct murder punchline. |
| “Murder is legal in the state of California.” | Macdonald’s opening on the first Weekend Update after Simpson’s acquittal in October 1995. | It framed the verdict as a license to commit murder, a deliberately inflammatory overstatement. |
| “Murderer” and “Non-Murderer” sections | In December 1997, Macdonald joked about a Los Angeles restaurant that had refused to seat Simpson and then compensated him. | It carried the same accusation into a mundane setting, imagining that the restaurant would sort diners by whether they were murderers. |
The first line is preserved in a fan-maintained transcript of the September 30, 1995 segment; the Los Angeles Times’ December 23, 1995 profile quoted a version as “lucky stabbing hat.” The Washington Post reported the post-acquittal opening and identified the restaurant joke as Macdonald’s last O.J. joke on the show. The joke examples and their respective contexts are also reproduced in the September 30, 1995 transcript.
What made the jokes controversial
The controversy was rooted in both subject and timing. Macdonald joked about a murder case while it was still being tried, turned an alleged piece of evidence into comic business, and then used the acquittal as the setup for a line that implied the justice system had made murder legal. That approach did not simply make light of celebrity news; it used the gravity of the case as the joke’s central premise.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
A transcript of a 1994 segment records an earlier joke about Simpson’s lawyers robbing them, followed by a notation that the audience sounded uncomfortable. The same transcript includes a fictional juror admitting not to have followed the trial, to which Macdonald responds that deciding guilt is “your business.” This is evidence of a reaction in that recorded segment, not proof of how all viewers or the public felt. The transcript is fan-maintained, rather than an official NBC record: SNL Transcripts Tonight’s 1994 Weekend Update transcript.
Did the O.J. jokes get Macdonald removed from Weekend Update?
It is often suggested that Macdonald’s Simpson jokes contributed to his departure from the anchor desk, but the available accounts do not establish that as the cause. In January 1998, NBC executive Don Ohlmeyer said Weekend Update had become stale and “wasn’t very funny,” and said a change was needed. He denied that the Simpson material influenced his decision, calling the suggestion “goofy,” according to the Washington Post’s January 16, 1998 report.
Macdonald was replaced at the desk by Colin Quinn but remained in the cast for a time. The jokes became closely associated with the change, yet Ohlmeyer’s stated rationale and denial mean it would be inaccurate to present their role as proven.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What Macdonald said about trusting a joke
In the 1995 Los Angeles Times interview, Macdonald explained his approach this way: “If you don’t believe in the joke, why do it in the first place?” He also said: “Don’t let the audience be the judge of what’s funny. You either think it’s funny or you don’t. That’s the problem with comedy–it’s so subjective that you really can’t take other people’s opinions seriously.” The remarks offer context for his willingness to pursue material that could provoke discomfort, without establishing how any particular viewer responded.
Quick Recap
Best Value
Rank #3
- 12 DVDs of the best episodes from Seasons 1-5. Plus a 28-Page Collector’s Book telling the story of the show and cast
- 33 episodes with the original groundbreaking, irreverent, hilarious cast. Plus rare footage of the cast, including screen tests and interviews
- All-time classic sketches including “Land Shark,” “Word Association,” “The Killer Bees,” “Super Bass-o-Matic,” “Weekend Update,” and so many more
- Iconic characters including Coneheads, Samurai, Emily Litella, Chevy Chase as President Ford, Shower Mike, The Blues Brothers, Baba Wawa, and more! You'll also recieve special episodes including Chevy Chase's return to SNL with music icon Billy Joel, plus the historic 100th episode!
- Guest Hosts include George Carlin, Richard Pryor, Steve Martin, Candice Bergen, Paul Simon, and more
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
