The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Disney abandoned its effort to force Jeffrey Piccolo’s wrongful-death lawsuit into arbitration, announcing on August 19, 2024, that the case could proceed in court. The dispute followed an alleged fatal food-allergy incident at Raglan Road Irish Pub and Restaurant in Disney Springs. Disney’s decision changed the proposed forum; it did not admit fault or decide whether either defendant was liable.
What happened at Raglan Road
The lawsuit concerns dinner on October 5, 2023, at Raglan Road Irish Pub and Restaurant in Disney Springs. According to the complaint, Kanokporn Tangsuan had severe dairy and nut allergies, and she and her party asked for food that was free of those allergens. The complaint alleges that Tangsuan later died from anaphylaxis. The allegations and reported medical-examiner findings are part of the case record, not a court finding of liability.
Jeffrey Piccolo filed the case as personal representative of Tangsuan’s estate. The defendants are Great Irish Pubs Florida, which operates Raglan Road, and Walt Disney Parks and Resorts U.S., Inc. The Associated Press reported that the complaint sought damages exceeding $50,000; that is a claimed amount, not an award. The case was filed in Orange County, Florida, under case number 2024-CA-001616-O. The Associated Press reported on the filing and allegations.
Why Disney sought arbitration
On May 31, 2024, Walt Disney Parks and Resorts U.S. filed a motion asking the court to compel arbitration and pause the lawsuit. Disney argued that Piccolo had accepted arbitration terms through a Disney+ trial and a later park-ticket purchase. The motion did not ask the court to decide the underlying negligence allegations; it sought to move the dispute out of court and into arbitration. The motion to compel arbitration is Disney’s filing and states its position, not a judicial ruling.
Recommended Free Tools
#1 Best Overall
- Medical Alert Bracelet: The product is a medical alert bracelet with a stainless steel brushed square plate and a adjustable band made of latex-free PVC. It fits wrist sizes from 5 to 6 1/2 inches and is easy to adjust for comfortable wear;
- Pre-engraving on your medical bracelet: on the front sides of the square plate pre-engraved medical condition 'NUT ALLERGY' , laser-engraved easy-to-read black text. This ensures that vital medical information is clearly communicated and easily readable in any situation, prioritizing wearer safety and peace of mind;
- Comfortable and Easy to Wear: The medical bracelet is designed for comfortable wear and easy adjustment, ensuring that it fits well on the wearer's wrist;
- Comes with Medical Alert Wallet Card: The medical id bracelet comes with a medical alert wallet card that can be used to provide important information about the wearer's medical condition in an emergency;
- Perfect Gift:This medical alert id bracelet comes in white gift box packaging or cute cartoon blister packaging, making it a great gift option for a son, daughter, brother, or sister.
The plaintiff opposed the motion. Piccolo’s August 2 filing argued that the Disney agreements should not govern the estate’s wrongful-death claims, which arose from a restaurant meal rather than use of Disney+. The case docket listing identifies the opposition filing and case number. The competing arguments raised whether online terms accepted for one service could apply to claims about a separate event; the court did not resolve that question before Disney withdrew its request.
Disney’s relationship to the restaurant
The motion characterized Great Irish Pubs Florida as the restaurant’s independent owner and operator and Disney as the property’s lessor. The complaint, by contrast, alleged an agency relationship and cited Disney’s descriptions of allergy accommodations as part of its asserted basis for Disney responsibility. Those are the parties’ respective positions, not findings establishing who was legally responsible. It would be inaccurate to describe Disney as the restaurant’s owner or operator based on the filings summarized here.
Rank #2
- 【MEDICAL CONDITION】: Laser Engraved with "PENICILLIN ALLERGY" ALL-CAPS (for readability) in Arial font, black silicone medical alert ID bracelet.
- 【Material】: 316L stainless steel metal plate and silicone band. Waterproof, very comfortable to wear, waterproof and Low-allergy.
- 【Size】: 8.46" Length and 0.40" width siliconce band, 1.5" Length and 0.47" width metal plate, adjustable to different sizes for men, women, children.
- 【LASER ENGRAVING】: It is easy to read and vibrant, permanent mark that will stand for five, ten or twenty years.
- 【PACKING】: Wrapped in velvet bag, Packaged in black gift box, good gift for your lover, family, friend and coworkers.
Disney withdrew the arbitration request
On August 19, 2024, Disney Experiences chairman Josh D’Amaro announced that Disney would waive arbitration and allow the lawsuit to proceed in court. He said: “At Disney, we strive to put humanity above all other considerations. With such unique circumstances as the ones in this case, we believe this situation warrants a sensitive approach to expedite a resolution for the family who have experienced such a painful loss.” The announcement was reported by the Associated Press.
Waiving arbitration was a litigation decision about where the case would proceed. It was not an admission of negligence, a settlement, or a decision on damages. The underlying claims still required resolution through the legal process.
Rank #3
- SAFETY WITH A SMILE: We believe in Safety First. AllerMates Food Allergy Bracelet is a fun yet functional medical alert bracelets for kids to alert their caretakers about food allergies and health concerns. This medical charm bracelet kit contains an adjustable silicone strap and a set of 6 allergy charms you can attach and customize according to your child’s need.
- ·6 CHARMING CHARACTERS: Providing safety with a smile. AllerMate’s customizable medic alert bracelet can be personalized based on your child’s allergy. This multiple food allergies cartoon bracelet kit comes with cute, playful character charms: Peanut Allergy Charm, Nut Allergy Charm, Dairy Allergy Charm, Egg Allergy Charm, Wheat Allergy Charm & I Carry an Epi Pen Charm.
- BRIGHT, SOFT & FUN: Your kid can play and run around all day without worries! This multi charm medical safety bracelet is made of durable, high-grade silicone material with an accessible lock to seal and secure around the wrist. This multiple food allergy bracelet is waterproof, latex and nickel free.
- AS UNIQUE AS YOUR CHILD: This kit comes with 6 charms & AllerMates has 20 other allergy awareness charms available for purchase. This silicone bracelet is easy to customize and wear. Just insert and position the food allergy charms using the keyholes to secure it. It has an adjustable snap with 3 slots to fit snugly around your child’s wrist.
- MOM FRIENDLY, KID APPROVED: AllerMates keep kids with food allergies safe by providing awareness in a visual, eye-catching way. AllerMates offer a wide selection of medical accessories for kids and parents. Alert their caretakers of their allergies in a simple way every day with AllerMates. Here to make life safer, easier, and more fun!
Court proceedings and arbitration: the difference here
| Issue | Court proceedings | Arbitration |
|---|---|---|
| Where the dispute is heard | In court, with proceedings conducted through the judicial system. | In a private dispute-resolution process, if the parties are bound by an applicable agreement. |
| Who decides | A judge or jury may decide issues assigned to them under the court process. | An arbitrator or arbitration panel decides the dispute under the applicable process. |
| What happened in this case | Disney said the lawsuit could proceed in court after waiving its request. | Disney had asked the court to compel arbitration; Piccolo disputed that the agreements applied to the estate’s claim. |
This case does not establish that Disney+ subscribers generally give up the right to sue Disney affiliates over unrelated events. The filings described arguments about these particular agreements and this particular claim; there was no ruling resolving the reach or validity of the terms.
Timeline
- October 5, 2023: Tangsuan dined at Raglan Road with Piccolo and a family member, according to the complaint.
- February 22, 2024: Piccolo filed the wrongful-death action in Orange County, Florida.
- May 31, 2024: Walt Disney Parks and Resorts U.S. moved to compel arbitration and stay the case.
- August 2, 2024: Piccolo filed an opposition disputing that the Disney agreements controlled the estate’s claim.
- August 19, 2024: Disney announced it would waive arbitration and let the lawsuit proceed in court.
What is and is not established about the case
The arbitration fight was a procedural dispute, separate from the merits of the wrongful-death action. The materials summarized here do not establish a final ruling on negligence or responsibility, nor do they confirm a current trial date. Readers should not treat Disney’s withdrawal as proof that the allegations were decided or that the case concluded.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Playful Dinosaur Design with Medical Alert Symbol:Features a fun 3D embossed dinosaur motif on a durable PVC band. The brushed stainless steel plate displays a vibrant red Medical Alert symbol—combining playful style with essential safety. Lightweight and built for daily wear.
- Adjustable & Comfortable Fit for All-Day Wear:Engineered for a secure, comfortable fit. The soft, flexible PVC band adjusts to fit wrists 5–6.5 inches. Ideal for school, sports, or everyday activities.
- Custom or Pre-Engraved Medical Info for Safety:Personalize with free laser engraving for critical emergency information. Choose custom text or select a pre-engraved option, including: Type 1 Diabetes, Penicillin Allergy, Asthma, Epilepsy, Nut Allergy, and Seizures. High-contrast black text ensures emergency readability.
- QR Code Version with Digital Health Profile:Choose the QR Code model for access to a digital health profile. After a simple one-time registration, securely store medical conditions, medications, and emergency contacts online. No subscription, no monthly fees—update anytime.
- A Thoughtful Safety Gift for Any Occasion:Packaged in gift-ready packaging. A practical and stylish gesture for birthdays, holidays, or any occasion for those who prioritize safety and style.
Rank #4
- MEDICAL ALERT: Your medical ID bracelet provides quick recognition of your medical conditions, which leads to faster and proper care in the event of an emergency situation. Most first responders and medical personnel are trained to look for medical ID during emergencies!
- HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL: Stainless steel metal plate and chain. Waterproof, very comfortable to wear, waterproof and Low-allergy. Our Engraved words are large and can be easily read.
- DIMENSIONS: Weight:7.3g; The bracelet length is 18+4cm(7+1.6inch) adjustable to perfectly fit your wrist size. This bracelet has an extended chain that can be adjusted to fit most women's wrists.
- PERFECT GIFT: Designed to be highly visible to emergency responders, but also with elegance in mind. Finally a medical alert bracelet that is stylish and not an eyesore. Medical identification jewelry can save lives by providing first responders critical health.In an emergency,when you might be unable to speak for yourself,a medical ID bracelet speaks for you.
- Please feel free to contact us if you have any concern about this item. We will try our best to promise you an enjoyable shopping experience.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
