Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.
The strongest faith-based Christmas movie for a direct Nativity story is The Nativity Story; for a gentler animated take, try The Star or the short The Small One. This list ranks ten films by how closely they connect Christmas with Christian faith, how well their storytelling suits the material, their likely appeal for a family or seasonal rewatch, and how clearly their content can be assessed. “Faith-based” is a spectrum here: some films retell the Nativity, while others explore belief, grace, providence, or compassion without depicting Jesus’s birth.
How these ten films are ranked
The ranking gives the most weight to the strength of a film’s Christmas and Christian connection, then considers storytelling, tone, suitability for the intended audience, and rewatch appeal. A direct Nativity retelling ranks highly, but a seasonal classic can also qualify when faith is central to its story. These are editorial recommendations, not a claim that every title is explicitly Christian or suitable for every child.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Saving Christmas | $14.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Christmas Miracle | $5.70 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
![Christmas Angel [DVD]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51SlpA-b0gL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Christmas Angel [DVD] | $2.41 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
![The Complete Rankin/Bass Christmas Collection [DVD]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/518TRdfCVmL._SL160_.jpg)
|
The Complete Rankin/Bass Christmas Collection [DVD] | $42.59 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
A Charlie Brown Christmas 50th Anniversay Deluxe Edition (DVD) | $9.99 | Buy on Amazon |
The 10 best faith-based Christmas movies
| Rank and film | Faith and Christmas connection | Format and tone | Audience and content guidance | Viewing access |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. The Nativity Story (2006) | Direct dramatization of Mary and Joseph and Jesus’s birth, drawing on Matthew and Luke as well as other material. | Live-action biblical drama. | Apple TV’s US listing gives it a PG rating and a 1 hour 40 minute runtime. A Diocese of Raleigh resource informed by USCCB materials notes violent images. | Check current services and edition in your country. |
| 2. A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965) | Turns from Christmas commercialism to the Christian story; Linus recites from Luke. | Animated seasonal special; reflective and gentle in tone. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 3. The Star (2017) | An animal-perspective retelling of the Nativity, following Bo and his friends as they become part of the first Christmas. | Animated family adventure. | AFFIRM Films lists it as PG for some thematic elements; ratings are not a universal suitability guarantee. | Check current regional listings and edition. AFFIRM’s page links to a DVD retailer, but availability can change. |
| 4. It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) | Not a Nativity film; its spiritual resonance comes through providence, purpose, sacrifice, grace, and community. | Live-action classic drama with comic elements. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 5. The Small One (1978) | A boy’s donkey eventually carries Mary to Bethlehem, linking a personal story to the Nativity. | Short animated Disney film; gentle and child-oriented in presentation. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 6. Journey to Bethlehem | Musical retelling of Mary and Joseph’s journey. | Contemporary musical combining classic Christmas songs and new pop songs. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 7. The Bishop’s Wife (1947) | A bishop seeks guidance, and an angel helps restore his faith; it is not a Nativity story. | Supernatural Christmas comedy-drama. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 8. Christmas with The Chosen: Holy Night | A Nativity-focused special. | Christmas special with a performance by Andrea and Matteo Bocelli. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check the exact edition, country, and current services. |
| 9. A Christmas Carol (1984) | The George C. Scott version connects with Christian moral themes through transformation and rediscovered compassion, rather than Nativity storytelling. | Live-action adaptation of a seasonal classic. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
| 10. Miracle on 34th Street (1947) | Christmas-centered courtroom story about belief and faith, but not a Christian Nativity film. | Live-action holiday classic with a courtroom-comedy framework. | Rating information is not stated in the cited recommendation sources. | Check current services and territory. |
Why each film makes the list
1. The Nativity Story: the most direct biblical drama
For viewers who want a feature-length dramatization of Mary and Joseph’s journey and the birth of Jesus, this is the clearest starting point. It draws on the accounts in Matthew and Luke, but it is not a scene-for-scene transcription of the Bible: the Diocese of Raleigh’s USCCB-informed resource notes that the film also uses apocryphal traditions and filmmaker invention. The same resource flags some violent images, so parents should consider the child’s age and sensitivities rather than relying on a rating alone.
2. A Charlie Brown Christmas: an explicit Christian message in a compact classic
This animated special makes its faith connection unmistakable. As FOCUS notes, Linus recites a passage from Luke as the story challenges the season’s commercial excess. Its compact format and quiet, reflective approach make it a natural choice for viewers who want a familiar Christmas watch with a direct Christian message.
#1 Best Overall
3. The Star: an animated Nativity adventure
The Star retells the first Christmas from the perspective of Bo and other animals who become involved in the Nativity. That point of view gives the biblical setting a lighter adventure-story feel than The Nativity Story. AFFIRM Films lists the movie as PG for some thematic elements. Its page also offers family and Catholic discussion guides, which can help viewers talk through the biblical themes after watching.
4. It’s a Wonderful Life: a story of grace, purpose, and community
This is a faith-friendly Christmas classic rather than a film about Jesus’s birth. Its place on the list rests on themes of providence, sacrifice, community, purpose, and grace: it asks what one life means to the people around it. Choose it when you want a spiritually resonant story rather than a retelling of scripture.
Rank #2
- Factory sealed DVD
5. The Small One: a brief, gentle Nativity connection
This short Disney animation follows a boy and his donkey, whose journey ultimately leads to Mary’s trip to Bethlehem. It is the most concise option here for a family looking for a gentle story with a clear link to the Nativity, rather than a full-length biblical drama.
6. Journey to Bethlehem: for viewers who want a musical
This contemporary musical follows Mary and Joseph’s journey and mixes familiar Christmas songs with new pop songs. Its musical approach sets it apart from the more traditional dramas and animated stories on the list; it is a better fit for viewers who enjoy a modern, song-led retelling.
Rank #3
- DVD
- Pure Flix
- PURE FLIX ENTERTAINMENT
- 857533003202
7. The Bishop’s Wife: an angel story about renewed faith
In this classic, a bishop looking for guidance is helped by an angel who restores his faith. Its spiritual focus comes through the supernatural story and the bishop’s renewal, not through a depiction of the Nativity.
8. Christmas with The Chosen: Holy Night: a Nativity-centered special
This special focuses on the Nativity and includes a performance by Andrea and Matteo Bocelli. It offers a shorter, performance-oriented alternative to a feature film, though viewers should confirm which edition is being offered where they live.
9. A Christmas Carol (1984): a moral transformation, not a Nativity retelling
The George C. Scott version earns its place through the transformation at the heart of the story: a miser rediscovers compassion. Its Christian connection is moral and thematic, rather than an explicit account of Christmas’s biblical events.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
10. Miracle on 34th Street (1947): Christmas faith expressed as belief
This courtroom-centered Christmas story treats belief as its central question. It is a faith-friendly holiday film, but its treatment of faith is broader than Christian teaching and it does not retell the Nativity.
Best Value
Choosing a film for family movie night
- For a direct Nativity dramatization: Start with The Nativity Story if you want a live-action feature, or The Star if you want an animated adventure. The former includes violent imagery noted by the Diocese of Raleigh; the latter is rated PG for some thematic elements by AFFIRM Films.
- For a short, gentle option: The Small One offers a brief animated story connected to Mary’s journey to Bethlehem.
- For an explicit Christian Christmas message: A Charlie Brown Christmas directly turns to the story in Luke.
- For faith themes without a Nativity plot: Choose It’s a Wonderful Life, The Bishop’s Wife, A Christmas Carol, or Miracle on 34th Street, depending on whether you want a story about providence, renewed faith, compassion, or belief.
- For a musical: Try Journey to Bethlehem; for a Nativity-focused special with a musical performance, try Christmas with The Chosen: Holy Night.
Ratings and family labels cannot account for every child’s age, experience, or sensitivities. In particular, consult the specific content note for The Nativity Story if violent imagery is a concern.
Where to watch—and what to know about group screenings
A December 2024 Deseret News article listed titles from this group across services including Disney+, Netflix, Apple TV, Amazon Prime Video, Peacock, Hulu, and BYUtv, with some available to rent. That is a dated snapshot, not a guarantee of present availability. Catalogs differ by country and change over time, so search the exact film title in your region before planning a viewing.
For a home copy of The Star, AFFIRM Films’ official page links to a DVD retailer. Confirm the current listing, format, and marketplace before purchasing. The page says its DVD is licensed for home or personal viewing; a church, school, ministry, or organization screening requires an official site license. AFFIRM also says site licenses are not available for in-theater showings and that umbrella programs such as CVLI do not apply to these films. Check the current license provider and terms before arranging a group screening.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
