Nico Tortorella and Bethany Meyers’ love story is not a simple march from first meeting to engagement, wedding, and happily-ever-after. They met as teenagers in Chicago in 2006, moved through changing romantic labels and periods of separation, built a consensually non-monogamous relationship, and married in 2018 without presenting marriage as a return to conventional monogamy. Their public story is ultimately about negotiation: how two people repeatedly redefined love, commitment, gender, family, and partnership as their lives changed.
A relationship that kept changing shape
The most accurate way to understand Tortorella and Meyers is not as a couple who discovered one permanent definition of love. In interviews, they have described a relationship that has moved through several forms: boyfriend and girlfriend, lovers, best friends, and partners in a non-monogamous marriage. The labels helped other people understand the connection, but the couple repeatedly emphasized that no single label captured all of it.
Glamour reported in 2019 that they had been together for 13 years. That anniversary count included a complicated history rather than 13 uninterrupted years of conventional dating. Their accounts describe periods of romantic involvement, time apart, relationships with other people, reunions, and an emotional bond that continued even when the sexual or romantic part of the relationship changed.
That history is what makes their love story distinctive. The central question was not simply whether they would stay together. It was how they would stay connected while allowing the relationship itself to evolve.
#1 Best Overall
2006: Meeting in Chicago
Tortorella and Meyers met in Chicago in 2006 while attending an art school. They were teenagers, and contemporary accounts describe an early crush that developed into a connection lasting well beyond the circumstances in which they first met.
Their early relationship did not immediately become a fixed partnership. Instead, the pair remained significant to one another as they grew older, explored their identities, and experienced other relationships. That long period of development helps explain why their later marriage was described less as the culmination of a conventional courtship than as one stage in an ongoing partnership.
The years of changing labels
During the late 2000s and 2010s, Tortorella and Meyers described a relationship that could be romantic at one point and more like a close friendship at another. They dated other people, separated and reunited, and continued to regard each other as emotionally important. Their public descriptions do not suggest that every stage followed the same rules or carried the same expectations.
For the couple, the continuity was not necessarily a continuous sexual or romantic relationship. It was the decision to remain honest about what the relationship was at a given moment. That distinction matters because it prevents their story from being reduced to a dramatic cycle of breaking up and getting back together. The changes were part of how they learned what commitment meant to them.
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallCrashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minuteWhat non-monogamy meant in their relationship
By the middle of the 2010s, open marriage and polyamory had become central to the way the couple discussed their partnership publicly. Their arrangement allowed both people to date or form relationships with others. But they also made a point of distinguishing polyamory from the assumption that non-monogamy is primarily about group sex.
In their interviews, the more important subjects were communication, disclosure, boundaries, jealousy, and the responsibility that comes with freedom. They described learning how to talk about secondary and tertiary relationships rather than withholding information until it became a crisis. The public account was not that jealousy disappeared; rather, jealousy became something they had to acknowledge and work through.
This is why describing them merely as an open couple misses the most important part of the story. Their relationship structure depended on negotiated expectations. What partners could do, what they needed to disclose, and how they protected the primary bond were matters to be discussed rather than assumed.
Their story also illustrates why a historical description should not automatically be treated as a current one. Tortorella and Meyers have spoken publicly about non-monogamy, but the available record does not establish every rule of their private relationship today. It is accurate to describe non-monogamy as a major part of the relationship they discussed in the 2010s and around their marriage; it is not responsible to invent current partners or private arrangements.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute2017: A proposal after more than a decade
In 2017, Meyers proposed to Tortorella after they had been connected for more than ten years. The proposal arrived after a relationship history that had included change, distance, and other partners, making it less a declaration that the couple had finally become conventional than a decision to formalize the partnership they had built.
The couple also spoke publicly about the difficulties surrounding their choices. Family resistance, questions about sexuality, and the challenge of explaining a nontraditional relationship to outsiders all became part of the story. Their willingness to discuss those tensions gave the relationship a more realistic shape than a polished celebrity-romance narrative: commitment did not eliminate uncertainty, and openness did not eliminate difficult emotions.
March 9, 2018: Marriage for love and legal protection
Tortorella and Meyers married on March 9, 2018, at a New York City clerk’s office. They later held a more ceremonial exchange of vows, allowing the legal and emotional dimensions of the marriage to exist as separate but connected events.
Their explanation for marrying was both romantic and practical. Legal marriage could provide protections and recognition involving health insurance, hospital access, family-building, medical decision-making, and legal status. In situations where institutions automatically recognize spouses, marriage offered a form of security that a privately negotiated partnership might not guarantee.
Rank #3
At the same time, they were clear that marriage did not require them to abandon the relationship structure they had developed. The wedding was not presented as a conversion to monogamy. It was a legal framework around a partnership that remained, in their public description, nontraditional.
That combination is the key to understanding the ceremony. For Tortorella and Meyers, marriage was not proof that their relationship had become conventional. It was a practical foundation for a relationship that still operated according to values they had negotiated for themselves.
Gender, sexuality, and the importance of dated language
Gender identity and sexuality are also part of the couple’s public story, but they should not be flattened into a permanent label taken from a single interview. In interviews around 2019, Tortorella and Meyers discussed nonbinary or gender-fluid identity and the use of they/them pronouns. Tortorella’s public language about gender and pronouns has evolved over time, so those descriptions should be attributed to the period in which they were given rather than treated as an unchanging current statement.
Using the couple’s names is often the clearest way to discuss their story when a current pronoun preference has not been directly verified. The broader point is that the relationship’s fluidity was connected to a wider willingness to question inherited assumptions about gender, sexuality, marriage, and what a committed partnership is supposed to look like.
That does not mean identity and relationship structure are interchangeable. Gender identity, sexual orientation, and non-monogamy describe different aspects of a person’s life. The couple’s interviews brought those subjects into the same public conversation, but they should still be discussed precisely.
When their public story shifted toward family
Before parenthood, much of the attention surrounding Tortorella and Meyers focused on open marriage, gender, sexuality, and the social meaning of their partnership. Their public emphasis changed after they began discussing fertility struggles, miscarriages, and IVF.
The fertility journey became an emotional and personal part of their story rather than a footnote to the relationship. After announcing a pregnancy, the couple welcomed their daughter, Kilmer Dove Meyers Tortorella, on March 5, 2023. Accounts described a home birth and connected the name Kilmer Dove to family history and the couple’s symbolism around doves.
Parenthood also changed the subjects Tortorella discussed publicly. Interviews increasingly touched on birth, caregiving, sobriety, art, and the emotional impact of becoming a parent. Tortorella has described fatherhood as central to life and creative work, showing how the couple’s story moved from questions about the structure of their marriage to questions about how they would build a family within that structure.
2024: A second child and an extraordinary birth setting
In April 2024, Tortorella and Meyers announced that they were expecting a second child after moving their family to Florida. Their son, Pesce Pearl Meyers Tortorella, was born on October 10, 2024.
The birth took place during Hurricane Milton. The family evacuated to a hotel, but after labor stalled they returned home. The circumstances made the announcement especially memorable, although the available accounts should not be stretched into medical conclusions about the birth. What is documented is the sequence: evacuation, a change in plans, labor that stalled, and the eventual birth of their son on October 10.
The name has also been reported consistently in the strongest available coverage as Pesce Pearl Meyers Tortorella. Variant spellings should not replace that form unless a source is being quoted directly.
Recommended Free Tools
Where the public record leaves them
As of the available research record, Tortorella and Meyers are best identified publicly as spouses and parents of two children. The most recent substantive family reporting located was the announcement of Pesce Pearl’s birth in October 2024. A Getty Images event listing also records the pair attending a public event together in the Bahamas in May 2026, which is consistent with their continued public association.
That event listing does not establish the private details of their relationship. It does not prove whether they currently describe themselves as polyamorous, monogamous, separated, or anything else. No reliable court filing, direct statement, or high-quality news report confirming a divorce was found in the reviewed material, so social-media or Reddit claims should not be presented as fact.
The careful conclusion is therefore narrower and more useful: the public record supports their history as long-term partners who married in 2018 and became parents in 2023 and 2024. It does not provide a complete, current map of their private relationship rules.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Why their love story remains compelling
Tortorella and Meyers’ story stands out because it treats commitment as something built through repeated conversations rather than guaranteed by a label. They met young, changed alongside one another, tolerated periods when the relationship did not fit a conventional romantic pattern, and eventually used marriage as both a legal safeguard and an emotional commitment.
Their story is not a universal formula for relationships, and their public interviews do not turn non-monogamy into a simple solution to jealousy or conflict. What they offer instead is a case study in intentional partnership: honesty over assumption, negotiated boundaries over inherited rules, and a willingness to revise the relationship as identity, family, and circumstance change.
The Bottom Line
Bottom line: Nico Tortorella and Bethany Meyers’ love story is defined less by a conventional romantic timeline than by its continual reinvention. After meeting in Chicago in 2006, they navigated changing labels, publicly discussed non-monogamy, married in New York in 2018 for both emotional and legal reasons, and welcomed two children in 2023 and 2024. Their marriage is documented; the precise terms of their private relationship today are not.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →
