The Hardy Boyz’ New Brood run was brief and never grew into a distinct identity of its own—but calling it a disaster overlooks what the storyline led to. Matt and Jeff joined Gangrel in August 1999 after breaking with Michael Hayes; by the night after their October No Mercy ladder match with Edge and Christian, Matt was rejecting the New Brood label. The faction was short-lived. The rivalry it helped frame became a significant part of WWE’s tag-team history.
Why did the Hardy Boyz join Gangrel?
WWE dates the Hardy Boyz’ turn to the New Brood to August 9, 1999. They had been pursuing tag-team championships under manager Michael Hayes since June, according to WWE’s Jeff Hardy chronology. After the brothers broke with Hayes, they aligned with Gangrel, who had been turned on by Edge and Christian. The move placed the Hardys on Gangrel’s side of the conflict and set up a feud with Edge and Christian.
That makes the New Brood’s appeal easier to understand as a wrestling angle: the Hardy Boyz’ darker presentation and Gangrel’s involvement gave the rivalry a new frame. But the available chronology does not show the group developing a substantial story independent of that feud. That is a reading of what happened on screen, not evidence of WWE’s backstage plan.
How long were the Hardy Boyz the New Brood?
The New Brood label lasted roughly two months, from the August 9 turn to Matt Hardy’s rejection of it on the October 18 episode of Raw. The pivotal match came one day earlier, at No Mercy on October 17, when the Hardy Boyz faced Edge and Christian in a ladder match.
Recommended Free Tools
#1 Best Overall
- Recreate WWE rivalries and partnerships with 2 approximately 6-inch tall action figures in one collectible pack.
- Each figure features 10 points of articulation to play out signature moves and poses.
- Authentic ring gear and life-like faces detailed with TrueFX technology bring the Superstar figures alive.
- The set also includes 2 Showdown Stands and one Championship Base for display.
- Gift an iconic pair to fans or build a collection with these WWE Superstar figures to create even more epic match ups (each sold separately, subject to availability).
WWE’s No Mercy archival video description identifies the match as setting a new standard for ladder matches. The Hardys won, along with the managerial services of Terri Runnels, according to WWE’s chronology. The match was the payoff to the teams’ rivalry—not proof that the New Brood had become a lasting faction.
Why did the New Brood break up?
On Raw the following night, Matt Hardy made the on-screen shift unmistakable: “We are NOT the New Brood – we’re the Hardys.” A contemporary recap of the October 18, 1999 Raw records the line and describes Edge and Christian appearing to show respect after the ladder match.
Rank #2
- Celebrate the excitement of key WWE moments and capture all the thrills of realistic, main event matches with this WWE Retro App figure!
- Comes in 4.5-inch scale and has a signature move it can pose to and perform.
- Must-have collectible for WWE fans everywhere!
- Features cool retro packaging.
- With the app, WWE fans can scan the figure and play as that character in the WWE game!
The timing suggests the New Brood presentation was dropped as the rivalry reached its payoff. It does not establish why WWE made that choice backstage. The available sources do not document a creative explanation, audience rejection, or a decision to end the group because it had failed. The most grounded account is simply that the label was brief and Matt publicly reclaimed the Hardys identity immediately after No Mercy.
Why can the run feel like a failure?
The faction had little time to stand apart
A group that lasts only from August into October has limited time to establish its own character and stories. The New Brood’s most prominent arc was the Hardy Boyz’ conflict with Edge and Christian, so Gangrel and the faction name can feel like a transitional setup rather than a fully realized stable.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsRank #3
- The WWE Jeff Hardy Top Picks Elite Collection action figure is approximately 6 in tall and at authentic "Superstar Scale."
- Features highly detailed TrueFX technology for life-like authenticity.
- Recreate signature poses and finishing moves with 25 points of articulation.
- Includes interchangeable hands and entrance gear to capture more favorite moments.
- The WWE Universe can collect them all to make their collections elite (sold separately, subject to availability).
The match outlasted the label
In retrospect, the ladder match is the defining memory of this period, while Matt’s next-night declaration makes the New Brood name seem disposable. That contrast supports calling the faction underdeveloped or a misfire. It is a critical judgment based on the short on-screen arc, not a documented verdict from WWE or a measure of how viewers responded.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Why “disaster” goes too far
The evidence points to a short-lived faction presentation attached to a consequential rivalry, not a failed match or a documented rejection by audiences. WWE’s later retrospective on tag-team rivalries includes the Hardy Boyz–Edge and Christian rivalry among major programs spanning 1999–2001. The New Brood itself did not last, but the feud it helped frame remained important in WWE’s account of tag-team history.
Rank #4
- WWE Elite Legends Eddie Guerrero
- Elite Series 8 Custom Figure
Keep the distinction clear: the faction can be judged as underdeveloped without treating the entire period as a disaster. The ladder match delivered a major payoff, and the rivalry continued to matter beyond the New Brood name.
Was Lita part of the New Brood?
No. Lita’s association with Matt and Jeff began later, on May 26, 2000, when the Hardys helped her against Essa Rios. WWE identifies the trio as Team X-treme. Lita belongs to a later chapter of the Hardy Boyz’ story, not the 1999 New Brood run.
Crashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minuteWindows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallQuick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
