Sara Carton said she turned down Ben Mezzenga at the Love Is Blind altar because several unresolved doubts had built up, leaving her unable to say yes. In a March 7, 2025 interview with Us Weekly, she described concerns raised by information she received about Ben, conversations about values and religion that she felt were not progressing, and a persistent unease. She said no single allegation made the decision for her.
What Sara said led to her decision
Sara’s explanation was cumulative: she continued the relationship while hoping they could work through her concerns, but her doubts remained by the wedding. She told Us Weekly that she loved Ben and could not imagine him out of her life, yet still felt she could not agree to marry him.
“I had hesitations even though I was like, ‘I love this person. I can’t imagine him not in my life anymore.’ But I still knew I [couldn’t] say yes. It just wouldn’t sit right,” she said.
Claims she said she received
Sara said a TikTok reached her alleging that Ben had mistreated an ex. She said it raised concerns about trust and safety for her and her family, but she continued moving forward at the time. The interview reports Sara’s account of the allegation; it does not independently establish that the alleged mistreatment occurred.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →#1 Best Overall
- Love Is Blind Game: Will you find true love in the Pods? Secretly test your love compatibility with friends in this fun & flirty card game version of your favorite Netflix reality series, Love is Blind
- Couples Party Game: Adopt a secret identity & icon to answer questions to see who you REALLY connect with; at the end, announce the icon you had the most matches with & want to marry; that player reveals their identity & finds their match
- Game Night Favorite: Get on the same wavelength to find your match; keep everyone cracking up at the next bachelorette party, 21st birthday, or college party with a hilarious adult game for game night
- Funny Random Stuff For Adult Games Night: Throw the best party ever with more party games for adults & families: Decodables, Tell Me Without Telling Me, Would You Rather?, Dumb Ways to Die & more
- Spin Master Games & Toys: Looking for kids games, yard games & card games for adults, kids or teens? Find family favorite puzzles & games for family game night, travel games, kids puzzles & more
She also said she received social-media posts about Ben, including a claim that he had given business cards promoting his YouTube channel to past flings. According to Sara, a card or picture of it reached her five days before the wedding. She did not raise it with Ben then. This, too, is information she said she received, not an independently verified account of what happened.
Conversations that did not feel resolved
Sara said discussions about values, religion, and other difficult subjects did not seem to move forward. She felt she was repeatedly asking questions without getting enough in return. “Ultimately, throughout our relationship and continuing to talk about the values and having those hard conversations, I felt like we never progressed,” she told Us Weekly.
Rank #2
- FAKE IT AND MAKE IT: A hilarious board game for adults and family that combines inventing funny answers with not getting caught. Can you convince the guesser your answer is the right one?
- NO ANSWERS? NO PROBLEM: Some family board games are tricky, but here you get given the one correct answer and you invent the other (fake) answers so it’s a new board game that is perfect for all your friends and family
- DIVE IN:There’s something for everyone in this fast-thinking, bluffing, push your luck, family board game — creativity, trivia and even a little bit of sneakiness
- PLENTY MORE FISH IN THE SEA:It’s packed full of content, making it the ideal board game for groups of people who want to dive in again and again
- QUICK TO LEARN EASY TO PLAY:A board game for families that’s easy to learn and quick to play. Spend less time worrying about the rules and more time focused on having fun
Watching the wedding back, Sara said she realized religion seemed to matter more to Ben than she had understood from their everyday conversations. Seeing him pray with family members at the wedding confused her; that was her interpretation of the footage and their earlier discussions.
Why she described it as a feeling that something was off
Sara said Ben told her he loved her, but she questioned whether his words carried weight and wondered whether she was being too critical. Her account was not that one moment suddenly changed her mind: she described an ongoing unease that persisted despite her hope that the relationship could work.
Rank #3
- Crack the Code in a Unique Deduction Card Game: "I Know... You Don’t" challenges players to unravel a secret rule based on clues provided by each card played. It's a deduction card game where observation, logic, and pattern recognition turn every round into a thrilling code breaking game, perfect for those who love a mental challenge.
- Engaging and Interactive for Groups: Designed for 3 to 7 players ages 10 and up, this family card game is ideal for game night, a party, or classroom brain-training activities. The interactive format and rotating gameplay make it a great thinking and icebreaker game for teens, adults, and families alike.
- Strategic Play with Three Ways to Win: Players choose between playing a card, playing multiple cards, or trading in their hand, with each decision being a critical piece of the puzzle. This strategy card game tests your ability to identify hidden patterns while outsmarting your friends.
- Five Levels of Difficulty for All Skill Levels: With secret rules ranging from simple to advanced, this puzzle card game is built for replayability and scalability. Whether you're introducing younger players or challenging seasoned code-breakers, this cognitive game adapts to the moment for consistent, engaging fun.
- Perfect for Travel, Parties, and Quick Play: Compact and fast-paced, "I Know... You Don’t" is a 10 minute game that’s perfect as a travel game, party game, or just a fun brain game for any occasion. Whether you're at a gathering or on the go, it's one of the best hidden information games for keeping minds sharp and players entertained.
She later reflected that she might have paid closer attention to her intuition. “I should have probably listened to my intuition a little more, but we made it to the altar and that’s when I was sure,” she said. By the altar, she knew she could not say yes.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Who helped Sara put the relationship in perspective
Sara credited her sister Lisa, Lisa’s partner Kelsie, her brother, her mother, and her stepfather with supporting her. She said their help gave her perspective on a relationship that had moved quickly.
Rank #4
- Made for Family Games: Incohearent, the best-selling board game taking social media by storm, is now available in PG form for family game night hilarity, family reunions, or kids halloween games.
- Fun Games for All Ages: This card game is designed for 2 or more players ages 12+. It's the perfect funny gifts for gifts for teen girls, party games, family games for kids and adults, or entertaining road trip games.
- How To Play: Flip the timer and hold up a card so that other players only see the gibberish side. Everyone else has to guess the phrase before time runs out. Decode the phrase first to win the point.
- What's Inside: Each set contains 400 cards, a 1 minute sand timer, and gameplay instructions. With a range of family-friendly categories and mystery phrases, now everyone can get in on the viral fun.
- Tongue Twisting Fun: From family game night to travel games, Incohearent works for any occasion. Whether you want games for kids, games for teens, or games for adults and family, teen boys gifts it's always a hit.
What is established about the altar decision
Sara and Ben were participants in season 8 of Love Is Blind, and Sara declined to marry him at the altar. The available interview gives Sara’s explanation of her own decision; it does not independently verify the allegations she described or establish the pair’s relationship status as of October 2026.
Source: Sarah Hearon, “Love Is Blind’s Sara Received New Information About Ben 5 Days Before Wedding: What You Didn’t See (Exclusive)”, Us Weekly, March 7, 2025.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
