Isla Fisher missed Now You See Me 2 because she was pregnant during filming. In the story, Henley Reeves has a different reason for leaving: tired of waiting for answers from the secretive Eye, she walks away from the Horsemen. Fisher returned as Henley in the third film, Now You See Me: Now You Don’t, alongside Lizzy Caplan as Lula May.
Why Isla Fisher did not appear in Now You See Me 2
The casting change had a real-world explanation: Fisher was pregnant during production of the 2016 sequel. A 2016 Creative Screenwriting interview with writer Ed Solomon says the production replaced Henley with Lula, played by Lizzy Caplan, because of Fisher’s pregnancy.
That explains why Fisher was unavailable for the film; it is separate from the explanation the movie gives for Henley’s absence.
What happened to Henley in the story
Now You See Me 2 says Henley grew tired of waiting for answers from the Eye and left the Horsemen. Lula May then takes her place in the group. That in-story account is reported by ComingSoon.it.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute#1 Best Overall
- MAGIC MAKERS BRAND Bicycle Stripper Deck
- Includes Online Access to 10 Stripper Deck Tricks
- Highly Deceptive Close-Up Trick for All Skill Levels
- Precision Die Cut Cards for Pro Level Handling
- Magic Tricks and Card Decks by Magic Makers - Become the Magic
So the two explanations answer different questions: Fisher’s pregnancy accounts for the production decision, while Henley’s frustration with the Eye accounts for the character’s departure.
Henley’s return in Now You See Me: Now You Don’t
Fisher returned as Henley Reeves in the 2025 third film, Now You See Me: Now You Don’t. ABC’s Good Morning America reported her return when the trailer was released on April 30, 2025, and announced a theatrical release date of November 14, 2025. A later Moviefone interview with director Ruben Fleischer, published December 25, 2025, also lists Fisher as Henley and Caplan as Lula.
Rank #2
- TRICKS FOR BEGINNERS OR PROFESSIONALS: Card tricks are fantastic classic magic tricks
- PROFESSIONAL PERFORMANCE TUTORIALS - to make learning your tricks fun and easy
- MAGICAL ONLINE LEARNING INCLUDED - Sterling Magic experience includes video learning that will bring your magic to the professional level; simply scan the QR code and you can begin streaming your magic from your portable device
- COMPLETE INSTRUCTIONS Covers assembly and performance of various tricks with the Svengali Deck along with Ted's Learning Page for More Tricks
- WIZARD COIN – 1 Included with every order, insures that you are getting genuine Ted’s Sterling Magic product
Why Henley comes back
ComingSoon.it reports Fisher’s explanation that Henley had been occupied with her private life and returned because she cared about the subject of the new mission. The report describes the antagonist as connected to human trafficking and money laundering, and says Henley’s return is not about an ego dispute or romance with Daniel Atlas. ComingSoon.it attributes those remarks to a Screen Rant interview; they are best treated as a report of Fisher’s comments rather than as independently verified direct quotations.
Why the third film includes both Henley and Lula
Fleischer said he wanted both characters in the third film because Henley had been replaced by Lula “without much explanation,” and he wanted to see them together. The remark appears in Moviefone’s December 25, 2025 interview. It gives the sequel’s casting gap a follow-through: Lula’s role is not erased when Henley returns.
Rank #3
- Card magic for everyone with more than 50 amazing card tricks
- Two special trick decks included to have total control with your card magic
- Easy online learning with streaming and download access for fast results with routines for both the magic Svengali Deck and magic Stripper Deck
- Complete course In card tricks by Magic Makers
How to catch up on the films
For the clearest view of Henley’s arc and Lula’s place in the group, watch the films in release order:
- Now You See Me (2013): introduces Henley as one of the original Horsemen.
- Now You See Me 2 (2016): follows the group after Henley’s departure and introduces Lula May, played by Lizzy Caplan.
- Now You See Me: Now You Don’t (2025): brings Fisher back as Henley and includes Lula, according to Fleischer’s interview.
Release-order and cast details are listed in Moviefone’s franchise coverage. Where to stream or buy the films depends on current regional availability.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Powerful and Easy to Perform – One of the most impressive playing card illusions ever created. Amaze audiences with a thought-of card reveal using a specially prepared magic card deck that works every time.
- Made with Authentic Bicycle Quality – Professionally crafted using genuine playing cards bicycle for smooth handling and durability. Includes a full deck of cards bicycle in the famous bicycle standard playing cards design.
- Perfect for All Skill Levels – Whether you’re new to magic or a pro, this trick card deck is easy to learn yet powerful enough for television performances. Great for magic invisible effects, close-up shows, and street magic.
- Includes Everything You Need – Comes with the special magic deck of cards, printed instructions, and handling tips. Perform mind-reading style tricks with this versatile magic trick cards decks setup.
- Ideal Gift for Magicians & Collectors – A must-have for fans of bicycle card magic, bicycle marked deck tricks, and marked deck of cards routines. An excellent addition to any magic cards decks trick or trick deck collection.
Rank #4
- 50 AMAZING CARD TRICKS: Open the smart metal tin and discover enough secrets to create a complete card-magic repertoire. A Marvin's Magic deck, five special trick packets & a printed instruction booklet give aspiring conjurers ages 8+ both the props and guidance to begin. From the first baffling reveal to a flowing routine, this impressive set makes grown-up card magic wonderfully accessible. Everything a child needs to be a wizard with cards is waiting inside.
- 5 SPECIAL TRICK PACKETS: Reveal the secrets of United Nations, Psychic Vision, All The Hearts, Reds & Blacks and Mysterious Hearts. Each prepared packet creates its own intriguing style of card illusion. Explore each packet with the supplied guide and discover the secret behind its own amazing card effect. With clear instructions showing how the props work, a budding magician can turn these clever cards into a varied act that keeps the audience guessing.
- MARVIN'S MAGIC DECK INCLUDED: Take the essential tool of card conjuring straight from the tin and begin exploring what an ingenious pack can do. The deck is the tool behind the collection's 50 amazing card tricks and is ready to use the moment the lid comes off. From a first simple reveal to a confident finish, the cards stay at the heart of close-up card magic for conjurers ages 8 and up. Shuffle, deal and watch an audience try to work out what just happened.
- PRINTED INSTRUCTION BOOKLET: Unlock every mystery with a guide that keeps the secret methods close to the props they explain. A young magician can study one routine, rehearse the handling & revisit each stage until the reveal feels ready for an audience. The booklet turns the deck and five special packets into a structured collection of 50 effects. Each secret is explained clearly enough for a child of 8 to master powerful grown-up magic.
- AMAZE & BAFFLE ANY AUDIENCE: Give a young conjurer card magic built to amaze and baffle an audience. The prepared props do the clever work, so the performer can concentrate on timing, patter & the moment of astonishment. A well-rehearsed reveal earns the kind of reaction a child will want to create again and again. With 50 routines in the tin there is always another impossible finish waiting to be tried.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
