There were two different performers behind WWE’s 2011 Sin Cara rivalry—and two intertwined name histories. The blue-and-gold Sin Cara was the wrestler WWE described as CMLL’s later Mistico; the black-and-silver challenger was the original Mistico from Juarez. WWE’s match settled the rivalry on screen, not the real-world history of who had used the Mistico name.
Why were there two Sin Caras in WWE?
WWE presented the conflict as a contest between its blue-and-gold Sin Cara and a black-and-silver counterpart. The black-and-silver wrestler accused the other man of taking the Mistico identity and challenged him for the Sin Cara name. That was the television storyline; behind it were two performers whose careers had both been associated with the name Mistico.
In WWE’s October 4, 2011 interview, the company identified the blue-and-gold wrestler as the “second Mistico,” who had become CMLL’s Mistico before joining WWE. It identified the black-and-silver wrestler as the original Mistico, who had later wrestled for AAA and in the United States. The interview offers both performers’ perspectives, but it is WWE’s contemporaneous account—not an independent ruling on naming or intellectual-property rights. WWE’s interview, “Who deserves to be called Sin Cara?”
Was Sin Cara originally Mistico?
The original Mistico’s story, as recounted in WWE’s interview, began in Juarez, Mexico. WWE said he began wrestling under that name in 1999. After he left CMLL, the promotion gave the trademarked Mistico name to another wrestler, who debuted for CMLL in 2004. The original performer said he tried using “Mistico de Juarez” before changing names after pressure on local promoters.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →#1 Best Overall
- Bring home the officially licensed WWE action
- WWE Best of 2012 Series action figures in 7" Superstar Scale
- Kids can recreate their favorite WWE matches
- Features extreme articulation, amazing accuracy, and authentic details
- Collect all your favorites WWE Superstars
“I was forced to change my name,” the original Mistico said in the interview. That is his account of the change, not a legal finding about who owned or was entitled to use the name. The distinction matters: the original performer’s career history and CMLL’s later use of Mistico are real-world naming history; WWE’s later dispute over the Sin Cara identity was a scripted story.
How the two Mistico histories became a WWE rivalry
Blue-and-gold Sin Cara arrives
The blue-and-gold Sin Cara made his WWE debut on Raw on April 4, 2011, the day after WrestleMania XXVII, according to WWE’s profile and its match coverage. The October interview also refers to the performer’s U.S. debut in March; for his WWE debut, WWE’s profile and recap give the specific date of April 4.
Rank #2
- Ready to Rock! WWE Elite Collection action figures bring WWE Superstars to life in 6-inch scale.
- TrueFX Technology! Each figure features highly detailed life-like facial features.
- Dynamic Posing! Recreate signature moves with 25 points of articulation.
- Extra Pieces! Includes interchangeable hands and iconic accessories for play and display.
- Super Collectible! WWE fans can find their favorite Superstar figures (each sold separately, subject to availability).
WWE’s profile describes Sin Cara’s high-flying style and notes his later partnership with Kalisto as The Lucha Dragons. That profile is a historical record of the character, not evidence of the performer’s current ring name or employment.
Black-and-silver Sin Cara challenges him
In September 2011, WWE introduced the black-and-silver Sin Cara as the original Mistico. On screen, he said the blue-and-gold wrestler had stolen his identity and sought to take the Sin Cara name. In the 2011 interview, the original Mistico described the rivalry this way: “He took my identity, and now I’m going to take his.” It is an attributed statement from the performer, not an adjudication of the performers’ real-world name claims.
Rank #3
- Capture the blowout action of WWE Superstars with this Elite Collection figure!
- Featuring one of the WWE's biggest personalities and Champions, this bold and colorful figure comes ready to wreak havoc right out of the box!
- Figure has deluxe articulation, a detailed character expression, authentic ring attire and iconic accessories.
- Get all the WWE Elite Collection figures and let the battles begin!
- Each sold separately, subject to availability.
What happened at Hell in a Cell?
WWE’s September 29, 2011 recap says the blue-and-gold Sin Cara defeated the black-and-silver Sin Cara at Hell in a Cell. That is the match result within WWE programming; it did not resolve the separate history of the Mistico name. Read WWE’s match recap.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What happened after the 2011 rivalry?
A December 5, 2013 report by ProWrestling.net reproduced a WWE statement that the original performer remained under contract and that WWE would retain the Sin Cara character. The report also said Hunico had performed the role during the original performer’s absence. This is a snapshot of the situation in 2013; it does not establish either performer’s current ring name, promotion, or employment status. ProWrestling.net’s 2013 report.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Fan Favorites! WWE action figures bring Superstars to life in 6-inch scale.
- TrueFX Technology! Each figure is detailed with a life-like face for added collectability.
- Dynamic Posing! Fans can recreate signature moves with 14 points of articulation.
- Play and Display! Reenact favorite WWE Main Event matches or create new rivalries and moves.
- Super Collectible! WWE fans can find their favorite Superstar figures (each sold separately, subject to availability).
Rank #4
- WWE Elite action figures bring WWE Superstars to life in 6-inch scale!
- Each figure features highly detailed TrueFX technology for life-like facial features!
- Recreate signature moves and dynamic poses with 25 points of articulation!
- Includes interchangeable hands and iconic accessories for play and display!
- WWE fans can find a favorite Superstar figure or can collect them all (each sold separately, subject to availability).
Which parts are history, and which are storyline?
| Question | What the sources establish |
|---|---|
| Who was the original Mistico? | WWE’s 2011 interview describes the original performer as a wrestler from Juarez who began under the Mistico name in 1999 and later used “Mistico de Juarez.” |
| Who was the later CMLL Mistico? | WWE’s interview calls the blue-and-gold Sin Cara the second Mistico and says he had become CMLL’s Mistico before his WWE debut. |
| Who won the Sin Cara match? | WWE’s recap records a blue-and-gold victory over the black-and-silver version at Hell in a Cell. This is an in-story result. |
| Did the match settle the real-world name history? | No. The recap reports a WWE match result; it does not decide the performers’ historical or legal naming claims. |
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
