The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →The evidence does not support a reliable list of ten DC superheroes who cheated. The best-known example—Green Arrow and Black Canary—is more complicated than the familiar “serial cheater” label suggests: an official DC account says they were broken up when Dinah mistakenly believed Oliver had cheated. Superman’s relationship stories also shift across continuities, and several unusual DC romance plots are not straightforward cases of consensual infidelity.
Did Green Arrow cheat on Black Canary?
Oliver Queen and Dinah Lance have a long, repeatedly interrupted romance. DC’s history of the couple says their relationship began taking shape around 1970 and describes separations and reunions over the years. Before Oliver’s 1995 death, they had broken up after Dinah mistakenly believed he had cheated. As DC contributor Meg Downey put it: “And to make things even worse, Ollie and Dinah were actually broken up at the time, after Dinah mistakenly believed Ollie to have cheated on her.” (DC, January 11, 2017.)
That history complicates claims that a particular encounter amounted to Oliver cheating on Dinah: if the couple was already broken up, it was not an affair within their relationship at that moment. For the episodes often cited as evidence, ComicBook.com offers a further qualification: it says Marianne initiated a kiss while Oliver tried to get away, and that the Shado encounter was later characterized as assault rather than consensual infidelity. Those are the outlet’s interpretations, not a substitute for checking the original issues, but they show why a kiss or encounter should not automatically be counted as consensual cheating. (ComicBook.com.)
The CW’s Arrow is a separate continuity. Its storylines should not be treated as proof of what happened in the comics.
#1 Best Overall
Why a ten-name list would be misleading
Calling a character a cheater requires more than finding a kiss, accusation, or romance in a comic. A sound case needs to establish that the character was in an exclusive or committed relationship at the time, that the act was consensual, and that the character initiated or reciprocated it. The story’s continuity also matters: an imaginary tale, alternate universe, later retcon, or television adaptation may not describe the same version of the character.
On that standard, the evidence available for this topic does not establish ten individually supported DC superheroes who cheated. It supports a careful discussion of Oliver and Dinah, while the examples below illustrate why other apparent candidates cannot simply be added to a count.
Rank #2
What Superman’s relationship stories do—and do not—show
Clark Kent’s romantic history cannot be treated as one uninterrupted timeline. DC’s account of Lois Lane and Superman describes changes across eras, imaginary stories, Earth-2, the post-Crisis timeline, and the New 52/Rebirth transition. A claim about one version or period should not be generalized to every Superman story. (DC, March 27, 2018.)
A 2016 report raised a question about Clark dating Lucy Lane in Superman #12 near the announcement of a Superman/Wonder Woman romance in Justice League #12. The report noted that readers did not have a clear reason to place the Justice League story before the Superman one. That uncertainty is not enough to establish that Clark cheated. (ComicBook.com.)
Strange DC romances are not automatically infidelity
Two unusual stories sometimes surface in discussions of DC relationships, but neither is a clean example of a superhero consensually betraying a partner:
- Alfred and Catwoman: In Batman #22 (1944), Catwoman disguised herself as Belinda and romanced Alfred. The premise is a disguise and deception—not a straightforward example of a superhero choosing to cheat on a partner.
- Jimmy Olsen and Bruna: In Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen #98, Superman pressured Jimmy to return the affections of Bruna, a gorilla. This is a strange, coercive romantic episode, not clear evidence of consensual infidelity.
DC recounts both stories in its overview of unusual pairings. (DC, February 11, 2021.)
Rank #4
How to judge a claim that a DC hero cheated
Before counting a comic-book storyline as infidelity, check the details that determine what the scene actually means:
- Relationship status: Were the characters still together, and was the relationship understood to be exclusive?
- Consent and agency: Was the act consensual, and did the hero initiate or willingly reciprocate it? An assault or unwanted kiss is not consensual cheating.
- What the story establishes: Is there an affair, or only suspicion, an accusation, a kiss, or a later reinterpretation?
- Continuity: Is the event in the main continuity, an alternate setting, an imaginary story, or an adaptation?
- Publication context: Which issue and era does the claim refer to? DC’s timelines and relationships change, so the context can alter the answer.
Applied to the familiar Green Arrow case, those checks change the headline conclusion: DC says Oliver and Dinah were broken up when she mistakenly believed he had cheated, while the cited secondary account disputes treating the Marianne and Shado incidents as consensual affairs. For Superman, the Lucy Lane story remains a timeline question, not established proof of cheating. These sources do not provide a substantiated roster of ten.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors2Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches3Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsQuick Recap
Best Value
- Diverse 10-Comic Pack: Includes an exciting mix of All Different Comic Publishers - A Minimum of Five different including Marvel, DC, Image, First, Dark Horse, Malibu, and More! Plus you will receive a greeat variety of superhero and alternate genre adventures with no duplicates in the set.
- Guaranteed Value: Each comic in the bundle is as old as 30-40 Years old up to current books, ensuring a collection worth well over the purchase price.
- Perfect for Collectors: An excellent starter pack or addition to any comic book enthusiast’s collection, with titles from both major and indie publishers.
- Surprise Selection: Unbox an assortment of unique stories from superheroes to indie gems, providing hours of reading entertainment with every pack.
- Great Gift Idea: A fantastic gift for comic lovers of all ages, perfect for birthdays, holidays, or special occasions for fans of diverse comic book worlds.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
