The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →These ten artists made solo work that struggled to match the reach, identity or staying power of their best-known bands. “Unsuccessful” here is relative, not a claim that every solo release flopped: chart performance, critical direction and cultural impact point to different outcomes. Some careers began strongly or ran alongside band projects, and not every departure was made to pursue a solo career.
What counts as an unsuccessful solo career?
A solo career can disappoint by comparison even when it includes hits, respected albums or a long working life. The examples below are selected for a gap between an artist’s solo profile and the influence or recognition of the group most associated with them. Where a source gives a chart position, the territory is named; qualitative descriptions are presented as judgments, not sales data.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
At Folsom Prison | $24.94 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
![Greatest Hits [2 LP]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41trytWkFrL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Greatest Hits [2 LP] | $38.81 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
![Abbey Road (Anniversary Edition)[LP]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41ZIjjsCJWL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Abbey Road (Anniversary Edition)[LP] | $22.98 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
![Back in Black [Vinyl] [Vinyl] AC/DC](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/31N6fcQofoL._SL160_.jpg)
|
Back in Black [Vinyl] [Vinyl] AC/DC | $25.98 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
Greatest Hits (Remastered) | $35.97 | Buy on Amazon |
Leaving a band and starting a solo career are not always the same event. Several artists below moved between group and solo work, and some pursued both. Their stories are useful less as a ranking of failure than as examples of how a distinctive band identity can be difficult to reproduce alone.
Ten careers that did not replicate the band’s impact
1. David Lee Roth — Van Halen
Roth’s solo career started with real momentum. Classical Music describes Eat ’Em and Smile (1986) as a strong beginning, but sees a change in direction on Skyscraper (1988), calling it slicker, and says A Little Ain’t Enough (1991) moved toward self-parody. WatchMojo says his solo career slowed during the 1990s and that he rejoined Van Halen in 1996. This is a case of a promising start losing force, not an immediate commercial collapse.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →#1 Best Overall
- Format: Vinyl...
- Released: 2020-08-07...
- Genre: Pop...
- Released: 2020-08-07...
- Genre: Pop...
2. Lindsey Buckingham — Fleetwood Mac
Buckingham’s solo albums never matched the scale of Fleetwood Mac’s best-known work. WatchMojo reports that a 1992 Buckingham album peaked at No. 128, but its cited material does not establish the chart territory or name the album, so that figure should not be read as a US or UK ranking. He reunited with Fleetwood Mac three years later, according to the same source. The return supplies a timeline, not proof that the solo work had no value.
3. Richard Wright — Pink Floyd
Wright’s 1978 solo debut is characterized by WatchMojo as receiving little fanfare. That is a qualitative description, not a documented sales or chart result. He returned to Pink Floyd in 1987. The contrast is between a modest solo profile and a group whose sound and public identity were far larger than any one member’s individual output.
Rank #2
- Guns N' Roses Greatest Hits was released in 2004 and has sold over 5 million copies
4. Gene Simmons — KISS
KISS released solo albums from all four members in 1978 as a management strategy, according to WatchMojo; this was not simply a case of one musician leaving to build a separate career. Simmons’ album reached No. 22 on the Billboard 200, while Paul Stanley’s reached No. 40 and Ace Frehley’s No. 26, as reported by WatchMojo. Those figures make “unsuccessful” a relative label: Simmons had a charting solo record, but the project did not displace KISS as his defining musical identity. The same account describes Peter Criss’s R&B direction as a critical failure, underscoring that the four albums had different outcomes.
5. Rod Stewart — Faces and the Jeff Beck Group
Stewart’s solo career was initially highly successful, so he does not fit a straightforward commercial-flop narrative. Classical Music instead points to a change in character: later work moved toward polished adult pop and standards, away from the rougher edge associated with his band years. His example belongs on a list about diminished continuity with a group-era identity, not one claiming that his solo career failed outright.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Rank #3
- The new Abbey Road release features the new stereo album mix, sourced directly from the original eight-track session tapes
6. John Squire — The Stone Roses
Squire’s post–Stone Roses career included the Seahorses, a band project, rather than a purely solo path. Classical Music argues that the Seahorses’ Do It Yourself did not approach the impact of the Stone Roses. Squire later released solo albums and increasingly focused on painting. The transition illustrates how a musician can continue creating without recreating the particular cultural moment of a landmark band.
7. Mick Taylor — The Rolling Stones
Classical Music describes Taylor’s solo career not as a disaster but as an unrealized possibility. He released solo material, yet did not establish a lasting musical identity comparable to the one he had as a member of the Rolling Stones. That distinction matters: a limited solo footprint is not the same thing as a failed body of work.
Rank #4
- Ships in Certified Frustration-Free Packaging
8. Steve Marriott — Small Faces and Humble Pie
Marriott’s first solo album arrived in 1976, after his time with Humble Pie, according to Classical Music. The article’s central comparison is that he did not find a later vehicle to match the stature of the Small Faces or Humble Pie. His solo career is best understood in that context rather than reduced to a story of personal hardship.
9. Roger Daltrey — The Who
Daltrey’s solo records charted, but they remained peripheral beside The Who in Classical Music’s assessment. Daltrey (1973) reached No. 6 in Britain and No. 45 in America; Ride a Rock Horse (1975) reached No. 18 in Britain and No. 14 in America; and McVicar (1980) reached No. 22 in the US. These figures show meaningful chart reach, not a commercial wipeout. Daltrey also identified the audience-expectation problem directly: “I think people find it very difficult to accept band members who have been in a band like the Who in a different capacity,” he told Marc Allan in a telephone interview.
Best Value
- Format: Vinyl...
- Best Sellers: Top Seller...
- Released: 2024-01-26...
- Genre: Rock...
- Format: Vinyl...
10. Izzy Stradlin — Guns N’ Roses
Marc Allan’s archived article says Stradlin’s solo album barely dented the charts. The account offers a contemporary qualitative judgment, not a chart number, so it supports a broad comparison with Guns N’ Roses’ prominence rather than a precise commercial claim. Stradlin’s case also shows how a guitarist’s role within a famous group may be more visible to listeners than his separate catalogue.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Why the band comparison can be misleading
A band is more than its most famous singer or songwriter: it can combine collaborators, a distinctive sound, timing and a built-in audience. Classical Music emphasizes that a weaker solo impact need not mean an artist lacked ability; context, chemistry and direction can change when the group is gone.
Reunions make a neat ending, but they are not a reliable test of solo failure. Conversely, an artist may never rejoin a former band and still have a comparatively modest solo profile. The examples here are selected cases, not evidence that solo careers usually fail.
Artists excluded from a simple failure list
Some familiar band-to-solo stories are too successful or too mixed to describe as straightforward failures. Official Charts’ UK records offer clear counterexamples: Björk spent 89 weeks in the UK Official Albums Chart Top 40; Debbie Harry had four Top 40 singles and five Top 40 albums; Gary Barlow had nine Top 40 singles and two No. 1 albums; and Lionel Richie had twenty Top 40 singles and three No. 1 albums. These figures reflect UK chart history, not a universal measure of artistic merit.
Other cases resist a simple verdict. Peter Frampton became a major star with Frampton Comes Alive!, and I’m in You reached No. 2 in America before later releases struggled to sustain that momentum. Paul Rodgers continued with Bad Company after Free, making “solo” an awkward label for his post-Free career. John Entwistle’s solo work retained his musicianship but followed a deliberately eccentric direction with less commercial appeal than The Who, according to Classical Music. In each instance, a single “success” or “failure” label hides more than it explains.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
