Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
The Zodiac Killer has never been identified, and no one has been charged with the murders. Arthur Leigh Allen was the most prominent suspect publicly named by police and investigated over time, but evidence reported about him included significant mismatches. Other names came from books, researchers, relatives, and media claims—not established identifications. Here is what was alleged about the major suspects, what evidence was cited or challenged, and what happened to them.
What counts as a Zodiac Killer suspect?
The case remains unresolved. The FBI says the murders did not fall under federal jurisdiction, so it did not open its own investigation; it assisted local agencies with handwriting, fingerprint, and cipher analysis. The FBI’s account distinguishes that assistance from a federal investigation.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Zodiac | Buy on Amazon | |
| 2 |
|
Zodiac - Director's Cut | Buy on Amazon | |
| 3 |
|
Zodiac - Die Spur des Killers | $10.20 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
ZODIAC - SPUR DES KILLERS (DIR | $20.40 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
Zodiac - Die Spur des Killers - Director's Cut (2 DVDs) | $89.00 | Buy on Amazon |
Suspect theories vary in origin and strength. Some were subjects of police attention; others were proposed by authors, relatives, private researchers, or documentary producers. A resemblance, a cipher interpretation, or a later recollection is not equivalent to a forensic identification. The 2024 academic paper on the solution of the Zodiac’s 340-character cipher says the case remains unsolved: decoding a message does not identify its author. The paper by David Oranchak, Sam Blake, and Jarl Van Eycke describes the cipher work.
Arthur Leigh Allen: the best-known police suspect
Allen became the dominant suspect in public accounts, in part through Robert Graysmith’s book and the 2007 film based on it. The circumstantial case included an acquaintance’s account that Allen had talked about killing people and using the name Zodiac before the crimes, a Zodiac-brand watch with a crosshair logo, and alleged proximity to some crime locations. These claims are not proof of guilt. HISTORY’s account of the suspect theories recounts the allegations and investigative history.
#1 Best Overall
Reported evidence also weighs against Allen. HISTORY says he did not match witness descriptions; his fingerprints did not match those from Paul Stine’s cab, his palm print did not match a print on a Zodiac letter, and handwriting samples did not match. Two searches of his home reportedly found no incriminating evidence. His DNA did not match a partial profile developed in 2002 from saliva on an envelope. The profile’s significance is contested, however: a specialist archive notes that the sample may have come from the outside of a stamp. A mismatch excludes Allen from that particular sample; it does not establish whose DNA it was. Allen died of a heart attack in 1992. The Zodiac Killer archive discusses the sample’s limitations.
Other widely discussed suspects
Richard Marshall
Marshall was a ham-radio operator and movie projectionist. The theory pointed to his having lived in Riverside in 1966 and later being near the Paul Stine crime scene, as well as interests or possessions said to resemble details in Zodiac communications. Those are circumstantial similarities. In a 1989 television interview, Marshall reportedly acknowledged similarities but denied being the killer; detective Ken Narlow assessed him as a poor suspect. Marshall died in a nursing home in 2008. HISTORY summarizes the theory and reported assessment.
Rank #2
Richard Gaikowski
Gaikowski was a San Francisco counterculture newspaper editor. A former coworker using the nickname “Goldcatcher” accused him and supplied recordings; a television segment presented a dispatcher’s impression that a voice resembled Zodiac’s. A researcher also argued that “Gyke” appeared in a cipher. The case therefore rests on an accuser, interpretation, and voice comparison rather than a demonstrated physical link. HISTORY reports that a police inspector regarded the accuser as lacking credibility and that police denied requests to compare Gaikowski’s DNA with Zodiac evidence. Gaikowski died in 2004. HISTORY details the claims and reported response.
Earl Van Best Jr.
Van Best’s son, Gary Stewart, argued in the 2014 book The Most Dangerous Animal of All that his father was Zodiac, citing resemblance, cipher interpretation, handwriting, and biographical claims. Key elements were challenged: the cipher method was questioned, the handwriting cited was reportedly a minister’s rather than Van Best’s, and the fingerprint resemblance required reversal. The book documents a suspect theory, not a settled identification. Van Best died in 1984. HISTORY reviews the theory and objections.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Rank #3
Jack Tarrance
Tarrance’s stepson, Dennis Kaufman, claimed Tarrance was Zodiac and presented what he described as evidence, including a hooded costume, photographs, and handwriting analysis. HISTORY reports that law-enforcement officials dismissed the material and that researchers challenged the examiner’s credibility. Tarrance died in 2006. The claims and criticism are summarized by HISTORY.
Donald Lee Bujok
Researcher Kevin Robert Brooks advanced Bujok based on the Lake Berryessa attacker’s reported statement about escaping prison in Montana, Bujok’s incarceration history, and interpretations of letters and symbols. Objections include a fingerprint mismatch, uncertainty over whether the prison reference was Montana or Colorado, and a difficult timeline connecting Bujok to the killings. Bujok died in 1993. HISTORY recounts the theory and its counterarguments.
Rank #4
- The disk has English audio and subtitles.
Other names found in suspect lists
- Lawrence Kane: The specialist archive characterizes the theory as lacking physical evidence.
- Ross Sullivan: Some theories rely on linking him to the 1966 murder of Cheri Jo Bates. Riverside police reportedly de-linked that crime from Zodiac in 2021, weakening that route to Sullivan. The Bates murder should not be described as a confirmed Zodiac crime. The specialist archive discusses the changed status of the Bates link.
- Paul Doerr: Proposed in a 2022 book; the specialist archive characterizes the case as circumstantial, with no forensic link.
- Ted Kaczynski: Zodiac theories involving Kaczynski are contradicted by documented whereabouts, according to the specialist archive.
These proposals do not have the same documented history of police attention as Allen. The FBI’s scanned records are available through the FBI Vault collection.
Gary Francis Poste: a 2021 media claim
The private group Case Breakers named Poste in 2021, citing a scar comparison and a claimed cipher solution. The specialist archive reports that the FBI said the case remained open and that the claim did not change its status; it also says cryptanalysts found the proposed decode did not follow from the ciphertext. Poste’s name should therefore be understood as a media claim, not an accepted identification. The specialist archive reviews the claim.
Recommended Free Tools
How to judge a suspect theory
For any proposed suspect, ask who made the claim and when; whether the person fits the known chronology and geography; what physical evidence connects or excludes them; how reliable and contemporaneous any witness identification is; and whether the argument depends on a cipher reading, resemblance, or later recollection. A collection of coincidences can explain why a theory attracts attention, but it does not by itself identify a killer.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
