Kamie Crawford is the clearest standout among Nev Schulman’s co-hosts beyond Max Joseph, while the guest hosts brought a wide range of energy and perspective to Catfish: The TV Show. This is a judgment ranking, not an official order or audience poll: it weighs on-screen rapport with Nev, useful questions, consistency, and each co-host’s contribution to an episode’s emotional or investigative arc.
“Co-host” here includes recurring partners and guest fill-ins, not every celebrity guest on the series. MTV described a later season as a search for Max’s replacement, but some people on this roster appeared before that transition. The available episode credits and clips document a broad set of co-hosts; they do not establish one definitive, exhaustive list across every special and episode.
How this ranking works
The ranking considers what viewers can assess on screen: whether a co-host works naturally with Nev, treats the people in the story respectfully, asks questions that clarify the situation, and adds something beyond reaction. Recurrence matters as context, but more appearances do not automatically mean a stronger contribution. The records identify appearances, not objective performance scores.
Paramount describes the series as following the documentary film Catfish, while Nev and Max Joseph formed its original host pairing. MTV later framed a season around finding Max’s replacement. Paramount Press Express: Catfish: The TV Show · Paramount Press Express: MTV announcements
#1 Best Overall
Guest co-hosts, ranked
The order below is an editorial assessment of the non-Max co-host rotation, not a claim that every person appeared in the same role, for the same number of episodes, or in the same era.
-
Justin Combs
Justin Combs is included among the co-host names in episode listings. The available record does not establish enough episode-specific detail to make a confident, fine-grained judgment about his individual contribution, so his placement is necessarily tentative.
-
Nick Young
Episode listings also identify Nick Young as part of the guest-host rotation. His documented appearance makes him part of this roster, but the available source record does not support a detailed comparison of his questions or on-screen dynamic with Nev.
-
Jane Carrey
Jane Carrey appears in the episode-credit roster. As with the other short-term fill-ins near the bottom of this ranking, the record confirms the co-host connection more clearly than it establishes a sustained hosting style.
Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy. -
Kimiko Glenn
Kimiko Glenn is another name documented in episode listings. A guest appearance can add a different point of view, but a limited record makes it harder to assess consistency across the qualities used here.
-
Laura Perlongo
Laura Perlongo’s place in the co-host rotation is noted in episode listings. She has a different relationship to Nev than a first-time guest co-host, but the roster evidence alone does not justify treating familiarity as proof of a stronger investigative contribution.
Rank #2
DVD Players for TV with HDMI,All Region Free DVD Player for Smart TV- Immersive Audiovisual Experience: Enjoy stunning clarity with 1080P HD DVD player, it brings vibrant colors and clear details to your screen, satisfying all your home entertainment needs. The enhanced brightness and contrast of this home DVD player deliver cinema-quality visuals, while the included HDMI and RCA cables ensure easy connection to any TV, projector, or home theater system.
- Durable and reliable design: This TV-specific DVD player DVD player for TV features a durable plastic and features excellent shock resistance, ensuring long-term, stable operation. Equipped with a precision laser tray, this HDMI DVD player plays discs from all regions smoothly (does not support Blu-ray discs). Note: Do not repeatedly press the eject button
- Universal Disc and USB Input: This region-free DVD player is designed with a focus on playback quality and universal compatibility with a wide range of disc and file formats. In addition to supporting DVD formats [DVD, DVD-R/+R, DVD-RW, CD, CD-R/RW, VCD, SVCD], this all-region DVD player can also play music, and photos from USB hard drives or flash drives, supporting file formats such as MP3, JPEG, WMA, to meet all your entertainment needs. Supports only the FAT or FAT32 file systems. The copy function supports copying CDs to USB. The maximum supported USB capacity is 32 GB
- Easy-to-Use Remote Control: The HDMI DVD player can be easily operated with a remote control with a range of up to 10 meters. It integrates a variety of functions, including memory playback, copying CD/MP3 format files to USB, A-B loop playback, slow playback, hiding/displaying subtitles, and adjusting the screen angle. The DVD player with remote control is very easy to operate and is ideal for elderly people
- Warranty & Package: Package included 1 x 1080P HD DVD Player,1 x Remote Control (Battery not included),1 x 5.05ft HDMI Cable,1 x 3.34ft RCA Cable,1 x User Manual
-
Selita Ebanks
Selita Ebanks appears on a compiled list of earlier guest co-hosts. Because that list is fan-maintained, her inclusion should be treated as a lead rather than definitive proof without checking the relevant episode credit.
-
Charlamagne tha God
Charlamagne tha God is likewise named in a fan-maintained roster of earlier co-hosts. His distinct public perspective could make for a different conversation, but the available evidence is not enough to compare his episode work reliably with the better-documented recurring hosts.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy. -
Cassidy Wolf
Cassidy Wolf is among the earlier names in the compiled roster. The credit trail is less secure than for names supported by official clips or later episode listings, so this placement carries more uncertainty.
-
Angel Haze
Angel Haze is listed as an earlier guest co-host in the fan-maintained compilation. That supports including the name cautiously, not claiming a definitive episode count or making a strong performance assessment.
-
Alex Shaffer
Alex Shaffer also appears in the compiled list. With no episode-specific evidence in the record to assess his questions or rapport, the ranking is a provisional placement rather than a verdict on a documented body of work.
-
Machine Gun Kelly (mgk)
Machine Gun Kelly, also credited as mgk, is named in the earlier roster. The source record does not establish a reliable basis for judging how his contribution compares across the series, so the placement remains cautious.
Recommended Free Tools
Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.Rank #3
Sale
LEMEGA PlayHD DVD Player for TV, HDMI, Multi-Region, HD 1080p Upscaling- HDMI TV READY IN MINUTES - Connect the PlayHD to any TV - including Smart TVs - using the included HDMI cable and you are watching in minutes - no extra cables to buy, no complicated setup required. Built-in HD upscaling displays your films at up to 1080p for a noticeably cleaner, sharper picture on modern screens. The full-function remote gives you complete playback control from your armchair - including pause, chapter skip, subtitle selection, audio control, and repeat.
- PLAYS ALL REGION DVDS WITHOUT RESTRICTIONS - The PlayHD is fully region-free and plays DVDs from every region worldwide, including Region 1 US discs, Region 2 UK and European titles, and all other regions, without any manual switching, unlocking, or configuration required. Whether your collection includes imported titles, discs bought abroad, or films gifted from overseas, the PlayHD handles them all straight out of the box. Your complete DVD library, whatever the origin.
- COMPACT AND TIDY FOR ANY ROOM IN THE HOME - The slim, space-saving design fits naturally into living rooms, bedrooms, kids' rooms, and smaller spaces without taking over your shelf or media unit. Lightweight and easy to move between rooms, the PlayHD is ideal for family movie nights, keeping children entertained during school holidays, and creating a simple home entertainment setup wherever it is needed most, including caravans and holiday accommodation.
- USB MEDIA PLAYBACK AS STANDARD - In addition to full DVD playback, the PlayHD features a front-panel USB port for playing MP3 music, JPEG photos, and AVI video files directly from a USB memory stick. Simply insert your drive and browse your files using the remote control. Supports USB drives up to 32GB formatted in FAT32. A useful everyday feature that makes the PlayHD a practical home media player as well as a reliable DVD player, all in one compact unit.
- EVERYTHING INCLUDED, READY STRAIGHT OUT OF THE BOX - The PlayHD arrives complete with HDMI cable, RCA cable, remote control, power adapter, and user guide, so there is nothing else to buy before you can start watching. Supports PAL and NTSC TV systems for full UK and European compatibility. Backed by Lemega's dedicated UK customer support team and manufacturer's warranty, giving you complete confidence and long-term peace of mind with your purchase.
-
Chantal Claret
Chantal Claret is another name surfaced by the fan-maintained roster. Her inclusion is not a claim of a recurring role; the evidence available here does not establish one.
-
Karrueche Tran
Karrueche Tran appears in the compiled list of earlier co-hosts. The record is useful for identifying possible fill-ins, but does not provide enough episode-level detail to support a confident comparative score.
-
Todrick Hall
Todrick Hall is listed among earlier guest co-hosts. A distinctive personality can change the tone of a conversation, but the available credit information does not show enough about his specific episode contribution to rank him higher with confidence.
-
Tyler Oakley
Tyler Oakley is also identified in the compiled roster. The available material supports acknowledging him as a reported guest co-host, while leaving the exact depth of his role and comparative impact uncertain.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREERepair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsFix Now →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEFix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy. -
Rashad Jennings
Rashad Jennings has stronger corroboration: official MTV clips identify him as a guest co-host. That makes his place in the rotation clearer, though the source record does not provide a measurable performance comparison with the others.
-
Elle King
Official MTV material identifies Elle King as a guest co-host. Her presence is part of the show’s varied fill-in approach, but a documented appearance alone does not establish consistency across multiple episodes.
-
Slick Woods
Slick Woods is identified in official MTV clips as a guest co-host. That official confirmation strengthens the roster entry; this ranking still rests on qualitative judgment rather than a published metric.
-
Tallulah Willis
Tallulah Willis is also confirmed in official MTV clips. She belongs among the recognizable one-off or guest voices in the rotation, though the evidence here does not support a detailed episode-by-episode evaluation.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy. -
Zeke Thomas
Zeke Thomas’s guest co-host role is documented by official MTV clips. His confirmed appearance places him more securely in the roster than names known only through compiled lists, while the comparative ranking remains an editorial call.
-
IO Tillett Wright
IO Tillett Wright appears on the earlier compiled roster. The available evidence supports cautious inclusion, but it does not establish enough episode-specific detail to make a strong claim about the contribution or duration of the role.
-
Kamie Crawford
Kamie Crawford ranks first because she moved from guest co-host to an ongoing host alongside Nev. That sustained role gives viewers a more substantial basis for judging rapport, questioning, and consistency than a one-off appearance can provide. Paramount Global Content currently lists Nev Schulman and Kamie Crawford as hosts, distinguishing her from the series’ many guest fill-ins. Paramount Global Content: Catfish: The TV Show
Why the roster is not a definitive all-time list
Official MTV clips confirm guest-host roles for Rashad Jennings, Zeke Thomas, Tallulah Willis, Slick Woods, and Elle King; episode listings add names including Kamie Crawford, Laura Perlongo, Jane Carrey, Nick Young, Kimiko Glenn, and Justin Combs. The earlier names in the wider working roster come from a fan-maintained compilation and should be checked against individual episode credits before being treated as settled. MTV: Catfish: The TV Show
Windows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallCrashes, No Sound, or Screen Glitches?
Random freezes, missing sound and display glitches usually trace back to one bad driver. Find and replace yours safely.Free scan · under a minuteThat distinction matters: the guest-host era was a rotation, not a single fixed lineup, and some fill-ins appeared before Max’s departure. A community discussion even asks, “Does anyone have a list of all the temporary cohosts that have ever been on the show?”—a useful illustration of the roster question, but not representative audience research. Reddit community discussion
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
