15 Best Blake Lively Movies, Ranked According to Rotten Tomatoes

The Town is Blake Lively’s highest-rated movie on Rotten Tomatoes, with a 92% Tomatometer score in the site’s current editorial ranking. The rest of the top 15 spans mystery-comedy, coming-of-age drama, survival thriller, period romance, crime, and family fantasy.

The Town is Blake Lively’s highest-rated movie on Rotten Tomatoes, earning a 92% Tomatometer score in the editorial ranking used for this list. But the ranking also shows how broad her filmography is: her best-reviewed work includes a Boston crime thriller, a stylish mystery-comedy, a coming-of-age ensemble, a survival thriller, a period romance, and family fantasy.

#	Preview	Product	Price
1		The Town	$2.37	Buy on Amazon
2		The Town	$19.81	Buy on Amazon
3		The Town (2010)		Buy on Amazon

Below are the 15 best Blake Lively movies according to Rotten Tomatoes’ current editorial ranking. The numbers and order reflect that guide’s snapshot, not a freshly recalculated sort of every visible percentage. Rotten Tomatoes’ separate Blake Lively filmography can display somewhat different scores as reviews and site data change.

1. The Town (2010) — 92%

Ben Affleck’s Boston crime thriller is the clear critical leader among Lively’s films in Rotten Tomatoes’ ranking. Lively plays Krista Coughlin, a supporting character connected to the film’s central group of bank robbers and to the complicated relationship between a criminal and a woman affected by one of his crimes.

#1 Best Overall

The Town

• Focus Points from "Ben's Boston,"
• "The Real People of the Town"
• "Ben Affleck: Director & Actor"

$2.37

Buy on Amazon

The Town is primarily an ensemble crime drama rather than a showcase built around Lively, but that is part of its strength. The film combines tense robberies, divided loyalties, Boston location work, and a steadily tightening emotional conflict. Rotten Tomatoes’ critics consensus highlights its tension, writing, cast, and Affleck’s direction.

For viewers starting with only one title from this list, The Town is the obvious choice—and it is also the strongest physical-media candidate. Depending on region and current stock, collectors may want to look for The Town on DVD or Blu-ray rather than assuming a particular edition is available.

2. A Simple Favor (2018) — 84%

Paul Feig’s glossy mystery-comedy gives Lively one of her most memorable roles: Emily Nelson, an impeccably dressed, secretive mother whose disappearance pulls Anna Kendrick’s Stephanie Smothers into a maze of revelations.

Rotten Tomatoes describes the film as a twist-heavy “mommy noir” elevated by the chemistry between Lively and Kendrick. That pairing is central to the movie’s appeal. Kendrick plays Stephanie as eager, chatty, and socially awkward, while Lively makes Emily controlled, intimidating, and difficult to read. The film’s fashion, humor, shifting alliances, and playful tone keep it from becoming a conventional disappearance mystery.

It is also an important entry for understanding Lively’s range: Emily is not simply a dramatic supporting role like Krista in The Town, but a deliberately constructed screen presence whose mystery drives the story.

3. The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants (2005) — 82%

Lively’s breakthrough feature role came as Bridget, one of four friends who spend their first summer apart while sharing a pair of jeans that mysteriously fits each of them. The garment becomes a symbol of continuity as the girls face romance, family complications, grief, and the uncertainty of growing up.

Rotten Tomatoes praises the film’s emotional sincerity and the ensemble’s chemistry. Those qualities explain why the movie remains one of Lively’s most enduring titles even though it is aimed primarily at a teen and young-adult audience. Bridget is energetic and confident on the surface, but the role also requires Lively to communicate vulnerability beneath that athletic, outgoing personality.

The film works best as a friendship story rather than as a simple romance. Its four storylines give the cast room to develop distinct personalities while preserving the sense that the characters’ bond is the real center of the movie.

4. The Shallows (2016) — 78%

In this lean survival thriller, Lively plays Nancy Adams, a medical student stranded near a secluded beach while a shark circles the shallow water between her and safety. The premise gives Lively most of the film’s screen time and leaves her to carry long stretches with limited dialogue.

Rotten Tomatoes credits the movie’s efficient construction, suspense, and Lively’s performance. The film turns a small physical space into a changing tactical problem: Nancy must assess her injuries, the tide, the rocks, the distance to shore, and the shark’s movements while trying to stay alive.

For anyone looking for Lively in a physically demanding lead role, this is one of the best choices on the list. It is more focused than many conventional creature features, using the restricted setting to make Nancy’s decisions—and her endurance—the main source of momentum.

5. Café Society (2016) — 70%

Woody Allen’s period comedy-drama places Lively in a large ensemble led by Jesse Eisenberg, Kristen Stewart, and Steve Carell. She plays Veronica Hayes in a story that moves between 1930s Hollywood and New York’s nightlife, combining romantic complications with a polished period setting.

Rotten Tomatoes highlights the film’s visuals and charming performances, while finding the story lightweight and predictable. That split is useful shorthand for the experience: Café Society is attractive and populated by capable actors, but its atmosphere may be more compelling than its romantic plotting.

Lively’s role is not as central as her parts in A Simple Favor or The Shallows, but the film shows her working comfortably inside a stylized ensemble and a period-comedy register.

6. The Private Lives of Pippa Lee (2009) — 69%

Rebecca Miller’s ensemble drama casts Lively as the younger version of Pippa Lee, the character played in later life by Robin Wright. The film examines the memories, choices, and hidden contradictions of a woman whose apparently settled adult life is built on a turbulent past.

Rotten Tomatoes characterizes the movie as offbeat and emotionally circuitous, with strong performances serving as its principal asset. Lively’s appearance is part of a larger portrait rather than a conventional star turn, and the role works because the younger Pippa must feel connected to—and distinct from—the older woman at the story’s center.

This is a useful pick for viewers interested in Lively’s earlier dramatic work and in ensemble films that prioritize character history over a tightly engineered plot.

Rank #2

The Town

$19.81

Buy on Amazon

7. Another Simple Favor (2025) — 59%

Lively returns as Emily Nelson in this Capri-set sequel, again opposite Anna Kendrick’s Stephanie. The follow-up expands the characters’ world with a new mystery, heightened settings, and another round of shifting motives.

Rotten Tomatoes’ editorial guide lists the sequel as Certified Fresh and credits its mystery, intrigue, casting, and comedy. Its displayed Tomatometer score is nevertheless lower than the original’s 84%, making the first film the stronger critical performer in the series according to this snapshot.

The sequel is best approached as a continuation of the original’s deliberately extravagant tone rather than as a straightforward attempt to repeat its premise. Lively’s Emily remains the main source of uncertainty: the film depends on the tension between her charisma and the question of whether she can ever be trusted.

8. The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants 2 (2008) — 66%

The four friends reunite while dealing with college, changing relationships, and the practical difficulty of maintaining a close friendship as their lives begin to move in different directions. Lively again plays Bridget, whose confidence and emotional directness remain important to the group dynamic.

Rotten Tomatoes praises the leads’ workable chemistry and the sequel’s message about staying connected. It does not reach the same critical percentage as the first film, but it preserves the ensemble’s central appeal: each character has a separate problem, yet the stories are tied together by a shared history.

Ranking note: Rotten Tomatoes’ current editorial guide places this film at No. 8 with 66%, above The Age of Adaline at No. 9 with 54%. It also places Another Simple Favor at No. 7 despite displaying a lower score of 59%. The list here preserves the guide’s numbered order rather than silently rearranging it by percentage.

9. The Age of Adaline (2015) — 54%

Lively stars as Adaline Bowman, a woman who remains physically young for decades after a miraculous event. The unusual premise creates an obvious question: what would it mean to live indefinitely while everyone around you ages?

Rotten Tomatoes finds the film’s treatment of that idea less compelling than comparable fantasy romances, but singles out Lively and Harrison Ford for their performances. The film’s emotional stakes become strongest when Adaline’s long life stops feeling like a gift and starts looking like permanent separation from ordinary human relationships.

Viewers who respond to high-concept romance and period settings may find more to appreciate here than the middling Tomatometer score suggests. The premise is ambitious; the criticism is aimed more at the execution than at Lively’s commitment to the role.

10. It Ends With Us (2024) — 55%

Based on Colleen Hoover’s novel, It Ends With Us stars Lively as Lily Bloom, a florist whose romantic relationship becomes entangled with cycles of love, control, and abuse. Justin Baldoni directed the film and co-stars opposite her.

Rotten Tomatoes describes the performances as earnest and says the film is strongest when it confronts the more provocative elements of its melodrama. That distinction matters: the adaptation is not simply a romance, and its central conflict requires the story to address the difference between affection and a destructive relationship.

The film’s subject matter can be difficult, particularly for viewers affected by domestic abuse. Its Tomatometer score reflects the critics’ response to the movie as a whole—not a verdict that Lively’s performance is without value.

11. Savages (2012) — 50%

In Oliver Stone’s crime drama, Lively plays O, who is romantically involved with two California marijuana entrepreneurs. The story draws her into a violent conflict involving competing criminal interests and an increasingly unstable power structure.

Rotten Tomatoes calls the movie messy while acknowledging Stone’s dark, lurid style. That description captures its deliberately heightened approach: Savages is interested in excess, brutality, and the collision between counterculture imagery and organized crime.

Lively’s role places her at the emotional and narrative center of a story that often prefers provocation to restraint. It is a more divisive viewing experience than the top entries here, but it remains one of her more substantial dramatic leads.

12. IF (2024) — 50%

Lively provides the voice of an imaginary friend in John Krasinski’s family fantasy about a girl who can see other people’s imaginary friends. The movie combines live-action characters with animated or digitally created companions and builds its story around childhood memory and emotional connection.

Rotten Tomatoes calls IF sweet and old-fashioned while criticizing its occasionally unfocused and complicated plot. That makes it a more family-oriented choice than most of the films above it. Its appeal rests less on the intricacy of its fantasy rules than on its attempt to connect imagination with the process of growing up.

Rank #3

The Town (2010)

Buy on Amazon

Lively’s contribution is vocal rather than onscreen, a reminder that her filmography includes performance work that is easy to overlook when focusing only on her live-action roles.

13. Accepted (2006) — 38%

This Justin Long-led college comedy features Lively as Monica. The story follows a student who creates a fake college after being rejected by real schools, only for the deception to become unexpectedly complicated.

Rotten Tomatoes criticizes the inconsistent plot but acknowledges that the film has a few laughs. Its premise gives it a familiar underdog-comedy shape, but the execution does not maintain the same level of discipline as the higher-ranked movies on this list.

For Lively viewers, Accepted is mainly a look at an early supporting performance, before the roles that established her as a major dramatic and comedic presence.

14. New York, I Love You (2009) — 37%

This anthology brings together multiple New York-set romantic stories, with Lively appearing as part of a large ensemble. Because the movie is divided into separate segments, no single actor or storyline carries the entire film.

Rotten Tomatoes says the anthology suffers from inconsistency but still contains worthwhile moments. That unevenness is a common risk in multi-director or multi-segment projects: one story may work emotionally while another feels slight or underdeveloped.

Lively’s appearance is best understood as one piece of a city-wide mosaic rather than a conventional starring vehicle. It is a lower-ranked title, but it may interest viewers who enjoy anthology structures and location-driven romantic films.

15. All I See Is You (2016) — 30%

Lively plays Gina, a woman who has been blind since an accident and whose life changes after her sight is restored. The premise creates an opportunity to examine perception, dependence, marriage, and the unsettling consequences of a long-awaited transformation.

Rotten Tomatoes finds the questions intriguing but ultimately describes the film as a stylish yet empty psychodrama. Its position at No. 15 marks the end of the requested top 15 in the editorial guide; Rotten Tomatoes lists five additional credited films beyond this point.

The low Tomatometer score should not be read as a simple assessment of Lively’s acting. Critics can respond negatively to a film’s writing, direction, tone, or thematic development while still recognizing a committed performance at its center.

What this ranking says about Blake Lively’s film career

The list does not point to one fixed “Blake Lively type.” Her strongest-reviewed films cover several distinct modes:

• Crime and suspense: The Town and Savages place her in darker stories shaped by violence, loyalty, and moral compromise.
• Mystery-comedy: A Simple Favor and Another Simple Favor use her polished, unreadable screen presence as a major storytelling tool.
• Friendship and coming-of-age: The two Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants films remain her most prominent ensemble-centered youth dramas.
• Physical survival: The Shallows demonstrates that she can carry a high-concept thriller with very little conventional dialogue.
• Period and high-concept romance: Café Society and The Age of Adaline rely on atmosphere, romantic tension, and carefully constructed visual worlds.
• Family and fantasy: IF broadens her work into voice performance and family-oriented storytelling.

The ranking also demonstrates the difference between a film’s overall critical reception and an individual actor’s contribution. A low or middle Tomatometer score does not automatically mean Lively’s performance was poorly received. Rotten Tomatoes’ consensus for The Rhythm Section, which falls outside this requested top 15, still praises her lead performance even though the film itself received a low overall score.

Which Blake Lively movie should you watch first?

How to read the Rotten Tomatoes scores

A Tomatometer percentage represents the share of counted critic reviews classified as positive; it is not a star rating and does not measure the strength of every individual review. Scores can also change when Rotten Tomatoes updates its database or adds eligible reviews.

For that reason, this article uses the editorial guide’s numbered order and displayed percentages as a dated snapshot. The separate celebrity filmography page may show different figures for some titles, including The Shallows, Café Society, Another Simple Favor, and The Age of Adaline. If you are comparing this list with Rotten Tomatoes directly, a discrepancy does not necessarily indicate an error; it may reflect a different page or a later update.

Collector’s note

If you are building a physical collection, begin with The Town DVD or Blu-ray, then check current editions of A Simple Favor, The Shallows, and The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. Disc availability, seller, region compatibility, price, and whether a release is DVD or Blu-ray can change, so verify the exact listing before buying. Streaming and digital-rental availability is likewise dependent on country and publication date.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Blake Lively’s highest-rated movie on Rotten Tomatoes?

The Town is Blake Lively’s highest-rated movie in Rotten Tomatoes’ current editorial ranking, with a displayed Tomatometer score of 92%.

Are these Blake Lively movies ranked strictly by Tomatometer score?

The list is based on Rotten Tomatoes’ current editorial guide, which ranks 20 credited Blake Lively films. It is not a strict re-sort of every displayed percentage, and scores can change as Rotten Tomatoes updates its pages.

Which Blake Lively movie should I watch first?

Start with The Town for the highest-rated film, A Simple Favor for stylish mystery-comedy, The Shallows for a Lively-led survival thriller, or The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants for friendship-focused drama.

The Bottom Line

Bottom line: Rotten Tomatoes’ current editorial ranking puts The Town first, followed by A Simple Favor and The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. Those three are the strongest starting points for most viewers, while The Shallows is the best choice for a Lively-led thriller and the Simple Favor films showcase her most distinctive comic-mystery persona.

Quick Recap

Bestseller No. 1

The Town

Focus Points from "Ben's Boston,"; "The Real People of the Town"; "Ben Affleck: Director & Actor"

$2.37

Bestseller No. 2

The Town

$19.81

Bestseller No. 3

The Town (2010)

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.